Pionsenay (died 1877) was an Apache leader and sub-chief of the Chiricahua. He is known for the brutality of his raids, his rivalry with the sons of Cochise, and for the murder of several white men including Medal of Honor recipient Orizoba Spence. His actions led to the forced relocation of the Chiricahua to the San Carlos Apache Indian Reservation.
Biography
[edit]Pionsenay was the brother of Skinya, a man of similar influence in the Chiricahua band.[1] In 1872, he had acted as a peace envoy of Cochise at the town of Janos.[2] After the death of Cochise, Pionsenay remained loyal to his brother during the schism between Skinya and Tahzay in 1875. The brothers and their allies relocated to the Dragoon Mountains.[3]
Sulphur Springs raid
[edit]In 1876, the Sulphur Springs overland mail station in the Arizona Territory was raided by a band of Apaches led by Pionsenay. The attack was instigated after an argument over whiskey sales. After Pionsenay brought his whisky back to camp, he quarreled with Skinya, and killed his two sisters when they tried to intervene.[4] On April 7, Pionsenay returned to the station and shot and killed Orizoba Spence, the cook, and Nicholas Rogers, the station operator.[5] The two were initially buried at the station, however, the bodies were later exhumed for interment at Fort Bowie.[6] Pionsenay raided further down the San Pedro River, killed two more men, and stole several horses.[4] He was unsuccessfully pursued by soldiers from Fort Bowie. The governor of the Arizona Territory subsequently demanded the removal of the Chiricahua.[7]
Pursuit by John Clum
[edit]John Clum, an Indian agent for the San Carlos Apache Indian Reservation, was sent to pursue Pionsenay and the rest of the Chiricahua in May 1876. He had the goal of relocating the band to his reservation. Skinya and Pionsenay argued with the sons of Cochise, Naiche and Tahzay, about how to proceed.[1] Skinya and Pionsenay wanted to continue the war, while Naiche and Tahzay sought to surrender.[7] Skinya was killed when Naiche shot him in the head. Pionsenay was shot in the shoulder by Tahzay, critically wounding him. Pionsenay fled with those loyal to him and refused to follow the sons of Cochise to the reservation.[1]
On June 8th, an injured Pionsenay sent a delegate to Clum. Pionsenay wished to negotiate peace, but Clum stated he would not accept anything less than unconditional surrender. Clum sent the delegate back with Tauelclyee and his posse to retrieve Pionsenay "alive, if convenient". Tauelclyee was successful. On June 13th, Clum delivered Pionsenay to the custody of sheriff Charles A. Shibell for transportation to a jail in Tucson. Pionsenay escaped soon after.[1]
Clum returned to pursue Pionsenay, but was unsuccessful. Although he was overall satisfied with how his mission went, he later stated that, "had not Pionsenay escaped I think my feelings would verge on ecstacy."[4]
In April 1877, Clum had tracked Pionsenay's band to Ojo Caliente. Clum continued to arrest and transport the Apache to his reservation, including nine members of Pionsenay's posse. Pionseney himself continued to elude Clum.[4]
Further resistance
[edit]The military pursued Pionsenay throughout the Dragoon and Chiricahua Mountains. It is possible that he rode with Zebina Streeter, known as the 'White Apache'. On September 1, 1877, Pionsenay met with fellow Apache leader Nolgee who had surrendered to the San Carlos reservation. Pionsenay convinced Nolgee and his followers to leave, and the group stole horses from the American-loyal White Mountain Apache Tribe to aid with their departure. The White Mountain band followed and recaptured several people and horses, but Nolgee and Pionsenay escaped to Steins Peak. They continued to raid, killing 13 people in the process. They descended down to Mexico with Juh.[2]
In November 1877, Pionsenay was killed in a battle near the town of Janos, Chihuahua.[2][8] He was possibly scalped by commander José Vasquez. Pionsenay was succeeded by an Apache named Broaches.[2]
References
[edit]- ^ a b c d Clum, Woodworth (1978). Apache Agent: The Story of John P. Clum. University of Nebraska Press. ISBN 978-0-8032-0967-1. Retrieved 8 August 2024.
- ^ a b c d Sweeney, Edwin R. (4 September 2012). From Cochise to Geronimo: The Chiricahua Apaches, 1874-1886. University of Oklahoma Press. ISBN 978-0-8061-8651-1. Retrieved 8 August 2024.
- ^ Utley, Robert M. (31 December 2017). "10. Removal to the Gila River". Geronimo. pp. 81–91. doi:10.12987/9780300189001-012. Retrieved 8 August 2024.
- ^ a b c d Bret Harte, John (1972). The San Carlos Indian Reservation, 1872-1886: An Administrative History. Vol. 1. The University of Arizona. Retrieved 8 August 2024.
- ^ A historical and biographical record of the territory of Arizona. (1896). Chicago: McFarland & Poole.
- ^ Fort Bowie Cemetery Graves, National Park Service
- ^ a b Utley, Robert M. (1977). A Clash of Cultures: Fort Bowie and the Chiricahua Apaches (PDF). Office of Publications, National Park Service. Retrieved 8 August 2024.
- ^ Lahti, Janne (5 October 2017). Wars for Empire: Apaches, the United States, and the Southwest Borderlands. University of Oklahoma Press. ISBN 978-0-8061-5933-1. Retrieved 8 August 2024.