THC Science

WP:UCFD/I

This is a comprehensive list of user category discussions, including deletion reviews, since May 1, 2007 that have resulted in a precedent-affecting outcome, defined as an an outcome that can be cited to support claims that particular principles regarding the retention or deletion of certain types of user categories do or do not have consensus support. (Thus, except in rare cases, this list excludes most nominations that end in "rename", "merge", or "speedy delete" per CSD C1 or CSD G7.)

Major discussions, defined as discussions that apply to an entire category tree and significantly affect consensus for a certain type of user category, are bolded and italicised. Discussions whose outcomes have been reversed, either through a subsequent discussion or via a deletion review, are crossed out; "no consensus" outcomes can be superseded but not reversed, except through deletion review.

Important note: This purpose of this list is to assist editors in identifying past precedents regarding user category inclusion and deletion. Editors are cautioned not to draw conclusions regarding the prevailing consensus for certain types of user categories based solely on the balance of "keep" and "delete" outcomes. The classification system provided herein is intended to serve as a time-saving device only, and is not a substitute for actually viewing the linked discussions.

Wikipedians by activity status

Wikipedians by alma mater

See Category:Wikipedians by alma mater

Wikipedians by high school

Wikipedians by award

Wikipedians by birth

Wikipedians by place of birth

Wikipedians by education

See Category:Wikipedians by education

Wikipedians by ethnicity and nationality

See Category:Wikipedians by ethnicity and nationality

Wikipedians by game

See also: #Wikipedians by gaming website

Wikipedians by video game

Wikipedians by individual

Wikipedians by interest

See Category:Wikipedians by interest

Wikipedians by language

See Category:Wikipedians by language

Wikipedians by 0-level language knowledge

Wikipedians by N-level language knowledge

Wikipedians by fictional or non-existent language

Wikipedians by non-ISO regional dialect

Wikipedians by programming language

See Category:Wikipedians by programming language

Wikipedians by lifestyle

Wikipedians by diet

Sometimes referred to as "by food"

Wikipedians by sexuality

Wikipedians who travel

Wikipedians by medical condition

Wikipedians by physical characteristic

Wikipedians by musical instrument

See Category:Wikipedians by musical instrument

Wikipedians by musician

Wikipedians by organization

See also: #Wikipedians who support/oppose organizations

Wikipedians by fraternity and sorority

Wikipedians by game show

Wikipedians by military organization

Wikipedians by professional association

Wikipedians by ownership

Wikipedians by computer hardware

Wikipedians by electronic device

Wikipedians by pet

Wikipedians by vehicle

Wikipedians by philosophy

See Category:Wikipedians by philosophy

Wikipedians by political ideology

Wikipedians by political candidate

Wikipedians by political party

Wikipedians by preference

Wikipedians by desire

Wikipedians who support/oppose

Wikipedians who support/oppose organizations

Wikipedians who like/dislike

Wikipedians by profession

See Category:Wikipedians by profession

Wikipedians by skill

See Category:Wikipedians by skill

Wikipedians by religion

See Category:Wikipedians by religion

Wikipedians by pseudoreligion

Wikipedians by software

See Category:Wikipedians by software

Wikipedian by sports team

See Category:Wikipedians interested in sports teams

Wikipedians by website

See Category:Wikipedians by website

@@ Line 60: / Line 60: @@
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/December 2007#Category:Wikipedians by alma mater: Williamsville East High School]] (delete)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/December 2007#Category:Wikipedians by alma mater: Christian Brothers College High School]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians by alma mater: Lower Merion High School]] (delete)
 == Wikipedians by award ==
@@ Line 168: / Line 169: @@
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/December 2007#Category:Wikipedians interested in Paul McCartney]] (delete)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/December 2007#Category:Wikipedians interested in Natural Sciences]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians interested in Teeline shorthand]] (delete, replaced with [[:Category:Wikipedians interested in shorthand]])
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians interested in books]] (depopulate of users)
 == Wikipedians by language ==
@@ Line 377: / Line 380: @@
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/December 2007#Category:Wikipedians that are easily depressed]] (delete)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/December 2007#Category:Wikipedians with astigmatism]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians with diabetes]] (delete)
 === Wikipedians by physical characteristic ===
@@ Line 423: / Line 427: @@
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/October 2007#Category:Wikipedians in Challenge Coin Association]] (delete)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/December 2007#Category:National Geographic Society Members]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians who participated in YLA]] (delete)
 === Wikipedians by fraternity and sorority ===
@@ Line 467: / Line 472: @@
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/August 2007#Category:Wikipedians who use computers with AMD processors]] (delete)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/September 2007#Category:Wikipedians who use Macintosh computers]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians who use Dells]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians who use Pentium D]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians who use HPs]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians who use Gateways]] (delete)
 === Wikipedians by electronic device ===
@@ Line 478: / Line 487: @@
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/August 2007#Category:Wikipedians who use a Tablet PC]] (delete)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/September 2007#Category:User owns a Pink Ipod]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians who use HD DVD]] (delete)
 === Wikipedians by pet ===
@@ Line 628: / Line 638: @@
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/December 2007#Category:Wikipedians against notability]] (keep)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/January 2008#Category:Wikipedians who support proprietary software]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians who support regiving]] (delete)
 ==== Wikipedians who support/oppose organizations ====
@@ Line 678: / Line 689: @@
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/January 2008#Category:Wikipedians who like The Simpsons Movie]] (delete)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/January 2008#Category:Wikipedians who like X]] (delete all)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Wikipedians who like X part 2]] (delete all)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians who like Clear and Present Danger]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians who like The Fugitive]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians who are Silver Surfer fans]] (delete)
 == Wikipedians by profession ==
@@ Line 708: / Line 723: @@
 ** [[Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2007 June 25]] (overturn)
 *** '''''[[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/August 2007#Category:Wikipedians by religion and all subcats]]''''' (keep)
+**** [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians by religion and related]] (no consensus)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/June 2007#Category:Sabbatarian Wikipedians]] (delete)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/June 2007#Category:Wikipedians who believe in Santa]] (delete)
@@ Line 853: / Line 869: @@
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/December 2007#Category:Wikipedians who trust Wikipedia as a reliable source]] (delete)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/December 2007#Category:Wikipedians who does not tolerate harassment]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians open to constructive criticism]] (delete)
 === Nonsense/joke/humour categories ===
@@ Line 925: / Line 942: @@
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/May 2007#Category:Singaporean Wikipedia administrators]] (speedy delete)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/May 2007#Category:Wikipedian Autograph Pages]] (no consensus)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/May 2007#Category:Wikipedians who don't own automobiles]] (delete)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/May 2007#Category:User rot13]] (delete all)
@@ Line 977: / Line 993: @@
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/January 2008#Category:Wikipedians who curse]] (delete)
 * [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/January 2008#Category:Sandbox]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians who fix double redirects]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedian mountain bikers]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians who are armigerous]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians who listen to FM 103.2]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Egocentric Wikipedians]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikilibertarians]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedian donors to Wikipedia]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedians from Fox Chapel, PA]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikimania 2007 Users]] (delete)
+* [[Wikipedia:User categories for discussion/Archive/February 2008#Category:Wikipedian football (soccer) fans]] (no consensus)

Revision as of 21:14, 15 February 2008