THC Science

Lin Zhijian's paper plagiarism case is an academic dishonesty incident in Taiwan's history. In July 2022, Lin Zhijian, a recent Department of Science graduate and Technology Management of Chung Hua University and the National Development Institute of National Taiwan University with two master's degrees and who announced participation in the mayoral election of Taoyuan City was accused by Wang Hongwei and others of copying two thesis. Zhonghua University and Taiwan University, respectively, both concluded that Lin Zhijian's thesis involved plagiarism and violated academic integrity, and their master's degree was revoked. Lin Zhijian was involved in copyright issues for plagiarism, which were also filed in civil infringement and criminal proceedings.

Lin Zhijian, who once served as a member of the Hsinchu City Council and the mayor of Hsinchu City is regarded as the future star of the youth of the Democratic Progressive Party. The controversy, which violates academic ethics, hurts Lin's Democratic Progressive Party in the 2022 Taiwanese local elections.

Background

Lin Zhijian, a member of the Democratic Progressive Party, went to the Department of Science and Technology Management to study^[1] for a master's degree when he was an assistant to Ker Chien-ming, a legislative member of the same party. His master's degree thesis, "Evaluation of the Satisfaction of Residents around a Science Park in China in TCSI Mode," was written by [3] under the guidance of He Lixing,^[2] and the oral was completed in July 2008.^[1] In addition, in April 2008, He Lixing, Lin Zhijian, and Wang Minglang (one of the oral committee members) jointly signed up for the "Academic Seminar on Management Strategy and Economic Development." They jointly published the article "Evaluation of public satisfaction in Hsinchu Science Industrial Park by TCSI Mode.^[1]"

Later, after Lin Zhijian's 2013 tenure at the National Taiwan University National Development Initiatives Institute, he was elected mayor of Hsinchu City Council after Professor Chen Ming-tong,^[3] under the guidance of, wrote a master's thesis on the leverage of the political and social foundation and its influence: in the 2014 Hsinchu mayor election as an example,^[4] in the January 2017 oral test through.^[5]

After mid-2022, when Lin Zhijian announced his candidacy for mayor of Taoyuan, Wang Hongwei, a kuomintang, held a press conference to accuse Lin of plagiarism in his dissertation. Plagiarism is regarded as an election issue, and the comments of all parties are mainly influenced by the positions of political parties.^[6]

Chung Hua University paper

Put forward a report

During Lin Zhijian's participation in the results of the 2018 Taiwanese magistrate, some netizens discussed his master's degree from Zhonghua University, but it did not arouse many echoes^[7].During the 2020 Taiwanese presidential election, Hsu Yung-ming, the Legislative Yuan of the New Power Party, once accused Lin Zhijian of plagiarism for his master's thesis at China University. However, Lin Zhijian and his guidance professor, He Lixing, had already clarified and denied it^[7].However, the power of The Times refuted Lin Zhijian's statement, indicating that the press conference in July 2020 accused the legislator Cheng Chen-chien of copying his thesis and did not mention Lin Zhijian^[8].

On July 5, 2022, Taipei City Councilor Wang Hongwei, a member of the Kuomintang, held a press conference to accuse Lin Zhijian of plagiarism in his master's thesis at Chung Hua University ^[9]^[10]She accused Lin Zhijian of copying the 2007 Hsinchu Science Park commissioned Chung Hua University to handle the research bidding case "evaluating the public satisfaction of Hsinchu Science Park in TCSI mode" final report "evaluating the surrounding resident satisfaction of Hsinchu Science Industrial Park in TCSI mode" (signed by Li Youzheng and Wang Minglang)^[11]^[12].Wang Hongwei hoped that Chung Hua University would properly investigate and suggested that Lin Zhijian volunteer to "return" his degree^[13].On July 6, Wang Hongwei and Taoyuan City Council candidate Ling Tao jointly held a press conference to announce that Lin Zhijian's paper from Zhonghua University was suspected of copying the text of Quality Monthly in December 2005, and the text similarity reached 94.1%.

Wang Hongwei publicly announced it again on July 28. She received a whistle-blower complaint showing that at an international symposium held in Beijing in October 2008, Wang Minglang and two other graduate students, surnamed Wang and surnamed Zhong, published an English paper titled "Applying the TCSI model to evaluate the stakeholder's satisfaction nearby Hsinchu Science Industrial Park (Chinese Translation: Using the TCSI model to evaluate the satisfaction of interested people near Hsinchu Science and Industrial Park)." Lin Zhijian and his thesis guidance professor, He Lixing, were not named in it. After comparison, the paper published in Beijing is the same as that published by Lin Zhijian, Wang Minglang, and He Lixing in the China University seminar, but the paper is "English," the chart content of the paper is the same in the same order, and all the conclusions and figures are entirely the same.

Lin Zhijian responded

Lin Zhijian responded that he participated in the bamboo science-commissioned research and also published a seminar paper with the same name as He Lixing and Wang Minglang^[11]^[14]. [17] He thinks his behavior is not plagiarism, and He Lixing and Wang Minglang also issued a written statement to endorse him^[14]^[15]^[16],Wang Hongwei in the Chung Hua university to bamboo administration plan application; according to the plan application, architecture planning is responsible by Wang Mingming, investigation and analysis is by Wang Mingming and He Lixing is responsible for the report by Wang Mingming and Li Youzhi is responsible for writing, Lin Zhijian is an unpaid research assistant and is responsible for "assist in the investigation," so Wang Hongwei says that Lin Zhijian "just help send questionnaire" rather than the original, and points out that the bamboo final report cover host is "Dr. Li Youzhi, Dr. Wang Minglang," no Lin Zhijian^[17].

On July 24, Lin Zhijian and lawmaker Cheng Yun-peng held a press conference, expressing in chronological order that his copyright ownership of the master's degree at the Discipline Management Institute of China is also his research process.

In addition, On July 6, Lin Zhijian appointed a lawyer to the Hsinchu District Prosecutor's Office to accuse the prosecutor Wang Hongwei of criminal law. After he was transferred to the jurisdiction of the Taipei District Prosecutor's Office, the North Prosecutor punished him^[18]. Wang Hongwei is fighting against Lin Zhijian, who was falsely accused; the north inspection is still under investigation^[18].

Academic review and results

In the examination and approval process, Lin Zhijian once attended an explanation.

On August 24, Chung Hua University announced the results of the review, confirming that Lin Zhijian's plagiarism was a serious violation of academic ethics, revoked Lin Zhijian's master's degree, and also sent a letter to the National Library to remove Lin Zhijian's paper from the shelves^[19]^[20].According to the statement, He Lixing, the guiding professor of Lin Zhijian's thesis, and Li Youzhi, the member of the oral examination, are the co-host and the host of the plan, respectively, but do not investigate the final report of his master's thesis and the plan, which is obviously negligent, and will be sent to the teaching evaluation committee for review^[21]^[22].

In early October, Lin filed a lawsuit with the Ministry of Education over the administrative action of Chung Hua University to revoke his degree.[31] After the trial of the lawsuit review committee, the Ministry of Education rejected the lawsuit filed by Lin Zhijian with the decision on January 19, 2023, of Taiwan Education Law (3) No. 1110094222, believing that Chung Hua University was punished in accordance with the regulations and the cancellation of Lin Zhijian's master's degree was not wrong^[23].Lin Zhijian also apologized on his personal Facebook fan page on February 14, 2023, for revoking the punishment of Zhonghua University, respecting the resolution of the Litigation Review Committee of the Ministry of Education, and not filing an administrative lawsuit^[24]^[25].

Copyright problem

Ling Tao and Yang Zhi-dou, a KMT Taipei city councilor candidate, went to the Taipei District People's Office on July 6 to accuse Lin Zhijian of violating the Copyright Law^[26]. Wang also accused the Taipei District Prosecutor's Office of Lin, his professors, and others of violating the copyright law^[27].

According to the contract between the Hsinchu Science Park Administration and Chung Hua University, the property rights of the works in the closing report belong to the Bamboo Science Administration. In a statement, the bureau, on the evening of July 6, asked Chung Hua University to make an explanation^[28].The administration has also publicly stated that no one has applied for authorization to use the closing report^[29].Bamboo Science Administration Bureau and Zhonghua University have exchanged many official letters and discussions^[30].On December 30, 2022, the bureau filed a civil lawsuit against Lin Zhijian for violation of the Copyright Law and filed a criminal complaint to the Hsinchu Local Procuratorate in Taiwan on January 3, 2023^[31].

National Taiwan University thesis

Academic ethics norms have been tightened

National Taiwan University announced on July 6, 2022, that from that day, all master and doctoral students must use the original comparison of text similarity before leaving the [87].

Impact of the election situation[edit]

In mid-2022, Lin Zhijian announced that he would represent the Democratic Progressive Party in the Taoyuan mayoral election [88]. His paper was publicly accused of plagiarism by many people, and the first whistleblower, Wang Hongwei, from the KMT, became a hot topic in the election campaign after Lin Zhijian announced his candidacy.^[6]。For example, the KMT suggested that Chen Ing-tong, president of GuoGuoan and party chairman, apologize for criticizing Lin for violating academic ethics and losing personal integrity.[89][90]

In the Democratic Progressive Party, Gao Jiayu, a member of the party, said that the dispute between Lin Zhijian's paper and the Hsinchu Stadium would have a negative impact on the northern candidates in the nine-in-one election, so some people suggested replacing Lin Zhijian.[91] Zheng Yunpeng, a party official elected by Lin Zhijian in Taoyuan and another member of parliament, opposed Gao's views and accused her of "apparently not reading the complete information and not understanding her party members."[92]

On August 10, the next day after the cancellation of his degree by Taiwan University, Tsai Ing-wen, chairman of the Democratic Progressive Party, said at a party meeting that "we are willing to believe that Zhijian did not copy" and instructed party members to believe Lin Zhijian. "We will shout to everyone that Lin Zhijian did not copy."[93][94] However, on August 12, after the DPP held a temporary election response meeting, Lin Zhijian said in a press conference that he would voluntarily withdraw from the election, with his assistant cadre Zheng Yunpeng taking over to participate in the Taoyuan mayoral election. [95]

In the 2022 elections, the Democratic Progressive Party was greatly defeated. The post-election official review report submitted by the DPP pointed out that after the outbreak of Lin Zhijian's paper plagiarism incident, the failure to timely and properly handle it caused public dissatisfaction. The hasty withdrawal from the election affected the trust of young people, and the whole incident had a negative impact on the election situation.[96]

explanatory note

1. This term was reported in the Freedom Times on January 11, 2023. The title and text of Chen Ming Tong and Lin Zhijian's paper plagiarism case are determined to be unjust.^[32]

2. ^ Yu Zhenghuang's master's thesis is entitled "Research on the Election of Hsinchu Mayor in 2014: An Analysis of the Political and Social Foundation of Lin Zhijian". The guiding professor is Li Bihan, and one of the oral committee members is Chen Mingtong (guiding Professor Lin Zhijian).[43]

1. ^ Then the head of the National Security Agency. The NNSA coordinated the institutions of the Republic of China, so Chen Mingtong was the head of investigator Yu Zhenghuang. [67][68]

reference material

References

^ ^a ^b ^c NOWnews, 今日新聞 (2022-07-05). "論文遭爆抄襲！林智堅：已是舊聞絕對禁得起考驗 | 政治快訊 | 要聞" [The paper was plagiarized! Lin Zhijian: It’s old news and will definitely stand the test]. NOWnews今日新聞 (in Chinese). Retrieved 2023-07-31.
^ Zhang, Yuzhen (2022-07-31). "獨／學位量販店？林智堅老師賀力行1人指導473本論文 | 林智堅論文爭議 | 要聞 | 聯合新聞網" [Controversy over Lin Zhijian's paper]. web.archive.org (in Chinese). Retrieved 2024-05-02.
^ Zheng, Xiuling. "民報 Taiwan People News | 【專欄】大家來比對林智堅兩碩士論文" [Let’s compare Lin Zhijian’s two master’s theses]. www.peoplenews.tw (in Chinese). Retrieved 2022-07-22.
^ 自由時報電子報 (2022-07-05). "台大碩論引用余正煌論文？林智堅︰我才是原創者 - 政治 - 自由時報電子報" [Lin Zhijian: I am the original author]. news.ltn.com.tw (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Retrieved 2022-07-05.
^ NOWnews今日新聞 (2022-07-24). "影／親上火線回應！林智堅：3個在先論文原創、無抄襲 | 政治快訊 | 要聞" [Lin Zhijian: 3 first, original paper, no plagiarism]. NOWnews今日新聞 (in Chinese). Retrieved 2023-03-15.
^ ^a ^b Cai, Huizhen. "林智堅論文門綠基層兩樣情！桃市長選情老神在在北市憂外溢效應「剉咧等」 -- 上報 / 要聞" [Lin Zhijian's thesis "Two Kinds of Love at the Grassroots Level]. www.upmedia.mg. Retrieved 2024-05-02.
^ ^a ^b "王骏杰; 巫鸿玮. 早被指控過林：受師指導討論" [Wang Junjie; Wu Hongwei. They have been accused before. Lin: Discuss under the guidance of a teacher.].
^ "吴亮贤. 時力：林應據實說明別模糊焦點" [Wu Liangxian. Shi Li: Lin should explain truthfully and not blur the focus.] (in Chinese).
^ "論文涉嫌抄襲風波再起！林智堅冷回2字" [The controversy over suspected plagiarism in papers has arisen again!] (in Chinese). Retrieved 2022-07-06.
^ "林智堅論文抄襲風波延燒　中華大學：收到檢舉就調查" [Lin Zhijian's paper plagiarism controversy spreads. Chung Hwa University: Investigate upon receipt of reports] (in Chinese). Retrieved 2022-07-05.
^ ^a ^b "李光仪. 師生變文不只林該交代" [Li Guangyi. It is not only Lin who should explain the story between teachers and students.] (in Chinese). Retrieved 2022-07-05.
^ "吴亮贤. 林智堅論文涉抄襲連錯字都一樣" [Wu Liangxian. Lin Zhijian’s paper was plagiarized and even contained the same typos.]. Retrieved 2022-07-05.
^ "一表看懂「林智堅論文門」　抄襲度87.8％！王鴻薇踢爆整本2.3萬字相同" ["Lin Zhijian Thesis Gate" plagiarism degree 87.8%! Wang Hongwei revealed that the entire 23,000-word book is the same]. Apple Daily. Retrieved 2024-05-04.
^ ^a ^b "她臉書貼王明郎教授聲明：林智堅研究合理" [She posted a statement from Professor Wang Minglang on Facebook: Lin Zhijian’s research is reasonable] (in Chinese). Retrieved 2022-07-05.
^ "被控論文涉抄襲　林智堅急滅火：藍營炮製「林智堅版宇昌案」我才是原創者！" [Accused of plagiarism, Lin Zhijian urgently puts out the fire: Lanying concocted "Lin Zhijian's version of the Yuchang case" and I am the original author!] (in Chinese).
^ 中央通訊社 (2022-07-05). "林智堅遭指論文涉抄襲中午記者會說明【直播】 | 政治" [Lin Zhijian was accused of plagiarism in his paper and explained at the noon press conference]. 中央社 CNA (in Chinese). Retrieved 2024-05-04.
^ "公開竹科研究計劃書「人力分工表」　王鴻薇：林智堅只是幫忙發問卷" [Publication of Bamboo Research Plan "Manpower Division Table" Wang Hongwei: Lin Zhijian just helped distribute the questionnaire] (in Chinese).
^ ^a ^b Qian, LiZhong. "王鴻薇指林智堅碩論抄襲挨告加重誹謗不起訴" [Wang Hongwei accused Lin Zhijian of plagiarism and was sued for aggravated defamation but not prosecuted]. Retrieved 2023-02-06.
^ "林智堅論文案中華大學認定抄襲撤銷碩士學位" [Lin Zhijian's dissertation, Chung Hwa University revoked master's degree after finding plagiarism]. Retrieved 2022-08-24.
^ "林智堅論文案提訴願被駁回審議委員：研究基礎能力不足" [Lin Zhijian's petition for filing a paper was rejected. Review committee member: Insufficient basic research capabilities]. Retrieved 2023-02-03.
^ "林智堅碩士學位又沒了！中華大學也認定抄襲　校長發3點聲明籲記取教訓" [Lin Zhijian’s master’s degree is gone again! Chung Hua University also identified plagiarism. The president issued a 3-point statement urging lessons to be learned.] (in Chinese). Retrieved 2022-08-25.
^ 中央通訊社 (2022-08-24). "中華大學認定林智堅論文抄襲指導教授賀力行與口委李友錚送教評會 | 政治" [Chung Hwa University finds Lin Zhijian's paper plagiarized]. 中央社 CNA (in Chinese). Retrieved 2024-05-04.
^ 聯合新聞網. "林智堅學位被撤首場訴願遭駁回教部提一點可再拚翻盤" [Lin Zhijian's first appeal against having his degree revoked was rejected. The Ministry of Education can make a comeback with some suggestions]. 聯合新聞網 (in Chinese). Retrieved 2024-05-04.
^ 聯合新聞網. "道歉了！林智堅撤回台大學位訴願案教育部證實「結案」" [Apologized! Lin Zhijian withdraws appeal for National Taiwan University degree]. 聯合新聞網 (in Chinese). Retrieved 2024-05-04.
^ Wang, BoWen. "放棄戰清白！林智堅道歉「論文寫作有瑕疵」：撤回台大學位訴願" [Give up the fight for innocence! Lin Zhijian apologizes for "flaws in thesis writing": appeals to withdraw his degree from National Taiwan University].
^ "林智堅論文再爆抄月刊藍告違著作權法" [Lin Zhijian's article was plagiarized from a monthly magazine again, and he was accused of violating copyright law]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). 2022-07-06. Retrieved 2024-05-04.
^ 自由時報電子報 (2022-07-07). "王鴻薇挨告加重誹謗今告發林智堅違反著作權、剽竊國家財產 - 政治 - 自由時報電子報" [Wang Hongwei was sued for aggravated defamation and now accused Lin Zhijian of violating copyright and plagiarizing state property.]. news.ltn.com.tw (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Retrieved 2024-05-04.
^ "快訊／林智堅論文與竹科報告雷同涉侵權竹科管理局：將請中華大學說明 | ETtoday政治新聞 | ETtoday新聞雲" [Lin Zhijian's paper is similar to Zhu Ke's report, involving infringement]. www.ettoday.net (in Traditional Chinese). 2022-07-06. Retrieved 2024-05-04.
^ "竹科管理局公文曝光！證實林智堅論文使用資料沒有申請授權" [Official documents from the Bamboo Management Bureau exposed! Confirmed that Lin Zhijian did not apply for authorization to use the materials in his thesis]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). 2022-07-21. Retrieved 2024-05-04.
^ "林智堅中華大學碩論抄襲涉侵權　科管局：將釐清合約內容" [Lin Zhijian's master's degree thesis of China University was plagiarized and involved in infringement. The Science and Technology Administration: Will clarify the content of the contract]. Retrieved 2022-08-25.
^ Lin, ZhiCheng. "竹科管理局告林智堅侵權國科會回應了" [Bamboo Management Bureau sues Lin Zhijian for infringement, National Science Council responds]. Retrieved 2023-02-05.
^ 自由時報電子報 (2023-01-11). "陳明通︰林智堅論文抄襲案確定是冤案 - 政治 - 自由時報電子報". news.ltn.com.tw (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Retrieved 2024-05-02.

[:0-1] NOWnews, 今日新聞 (2022-07-05). "論文遭爆抄襲！林智堅：已是舊聞絕對禁得起考驗 | 政治快訊 | 要聞" [The paper was plagiarized! Lin Zhijian: It’s old news and will definitely stand the test]. NOWnews今日新聞 (in Chinese). Retrieved 2023-07-31.

[2] Zhang, Yuzhen (2022-07-31). "獨／學位量販店？林智堅老師賀力行1人指導473本論文 | 林智堅論文爭議 | 要聞 | 聯合新聞網" [Controversy over Lin Zhijian's paper]. web.archive.org (in Chinese). Retrieved 2024-05-02.

[3] Zheng, Xiuling. "民報 Taiwan People News | 【專欄】大家來比對林智堅兩碩士論文" [Let’s compare Lin Zhijian’s two master’s theses]. www.peoplenews.tw (in Chinese). Retrieved 2022-07-22.

[4] 自由時報電子報 (2022-07-05). "台大碩論引用余正煌論文？林智堅︰我才是原創者 - 政治 - 自由時報電子報" [Lin Zhijian: I am the original author]. news.ltn.com.tw (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Retrieved 2022-07-05.

[5] NOWnews今日新聞 (2022-07-24). "影／親上火線回應！林智堅：3個在先論文原創、無抄襲 | 政治快訊 | 要聞" [Lin Zhijian: 3 first, original paper, no plagiarism]. NOWnews今日新聞 (in Chinese). Retrieved 2023-03-15.

[:1-6] Cai, Huizhen. "林智堅論文門綠基層兩樣情！桃市長選情老神在在北市憂外溢效應「剉咧等」 -- 上報 / 要聞" [Lin Zhijian's thesis "Two Kinds of Love at the Grassroots Level]. www.upmedia.mg. Retrieved 2024-05-02.

[:2-7] "王骏杰; 巫鸿玮. 早被指控過林：受師指導討論" [Wang Junjie; Wu Hongwei. They have been accused before. Lin: Discuss under the guidance of a teacher.].

[8] "吴亮贤. 時力：林應據實說明別模糊焦點" [Wu Liangxian. Shi Li: Lin should explain truthfully and not blur the focus.] (in Chinese).

[9] "論文涉嫌抄襲風波再起！林智堅冷回2字" [The controversy over suspected plagiarism in papers has arisen again!] (in Chinese). Retrieved 2022-07-06.

[10] "林智堅論文抄襲風波延燒　中華大學：收到檢舉就調查" [Lin Zhijian's paper plagiarism controversy spreads. Chung Hwa University: Investigate upon receipt of reports] (in Chinese). Retrieved 2022-07-05.

[:3-11] "李光仪. 師生變文不只林該交代" [Li Guangyi. It is not only Lin who should explain the story between teachers and students.] (in Chinese). Retrieved 2022-07-05.

[12] "吴亮贤. 林智堅論文涉抄襲連錯字都一樣" [Wu Liangxian. Lin Zhijian’s paper was plagiarized and even contained the same typos.]. Retrieved 2022-07-05.

[13] "一表看懂「林智堅論文門」　抄襲度87.8％！王鴻薇踢爆整本2.3萬字相同" ["Lin Zhijian Thesis Gate" plagiarism degree 87.8%! Wang Hongwei revealed that the entire 23,000-word book is the same]. Apple Daily. Retrieved 2024-05-04.

[:4-14] "她臉書貼王明郎教授聲明：林智堅研究合理" [She posted a statement from Professor Wang Minglang on Facebook: Lin Zhijian’s research is reasonable] (in Chinese). Retrieved 2022-07-05.

[15] "被控論文涉抄襲　林智堅急滅火：藍營炮製「林智堅版宇昌案」我才是原創者！" [Accused of plagiarism, Lin Zhijian urgently puts out the fire: Lanying concocted "Lin Zhijian's version of the Yuchang case" and I am the original author!] (in Chinese).

[16] 中央通訊社 (2022-07-05). "林智堅遭指論文涉抄襲中午記者會說明【直播】 | 政治" [Lin Zhijian was accused of plagiarism in his paper and explained at the noon press conference]. 中央社 CNA (in Chinese). Retrieved 2024-05-04.

[17] "公開竹科研究計劃書「人力分工表」　王鴻薇：林智堅只是幫忙發問卷" [Publication of Bamboo Research Plan "Manpower Division Table" Wang Hongwei: Lin Zhijian just helped distribute the questionnaire] (in Chinese).

[:5-18] Qian, LiZhong. "王鴻薇指林智堅碩論抄襲挨告加重誹謗不起訴" [Wang Hongwei accused Lin Zhijian of plagiarism and was sued for aggravated defamation but not prosecuted]. Retrieved 2023-02-06.

[19] "林智堅論文案中華大學認定抄襲撤銷碩士學位" [Lin Zhijian's dissertation, Chung Hwa University revoked master's degree after finding plagiarism]. Retrieved 2022-08-24.

[20] "林智堅論文案提訴願被駁回審議委員：研究基礎能力不足" [Lin Zhijian's petition for filing a paper was rejected. Review committee member: Insufficient basic research capabilities]. Retrieved 2023-02-03.

[21] "林智堅碩士學位又沒了！中華大學也認定抄襲　校長發3點聲明籲記取教訓" [Lin Zhijian’s master’s degree is gone again! Chung Hua University also identified plagiarism. The president issued a 3-point statement urging lessons to be learned.] (in Chinese). Retrieved 2022-08-25.

[22] 中央通訊社 (2022-08-24). "中華大學認定林智堅論文抄襲指導教授賀力行與口委李友錚送教評會 | 政治" [Chung Hwa University finds Lin Zhijian's paper plagiarized]. 中央社 CNA (in Chinese). Retrieved 2024-05-04.

[23] 聯合新聞網. "林智堅學位被撤首場訴願遭駁回教部提一點可再拚翻盤" [Lin Zhijian's first appeal against having his degree revoked was rejected. The Ministry of Education can make a comeback with some suggestions]. 聯合新聞網 (in Chinese). Retrieved 2024-05-04.

[24] 聯合新聞網. "道歉了！林智堅撤回台大學位訴願案教育部證實「結案」" [Apologized! Lin Zhijian withdraws appeal for National Taiwan University degree]. 聯合新聞網 (in Chinese). Retrieved 2024-05-04.

[25] Wang, BoWen. "放棄戰清白！林智堅道歉「論文寫作有瑕疵」：撤回台大學位訴願" [Give up the fight for innocence! Lin Zhijian apologizes for "flaws in thesis writing": appeals to withdraw his degree from National Taiwan University].

[26] "林智堅論文再爆抄月刊藍告違著作權法" [Lin Zhijian's article was plagiarized from a monthly magazine again, and he was accused of violating copyright law]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). 2022-07-06. Retrieved 2024-05-04.

[27] 自由時報電子報 (2022-07-07). "王鴻薇挨告加重誹謗今告發林智堅違反著作權、剽竊國家財產 - 政治 - 自由時報電子報" [Wang Hongwei was sued for aggravated defamation and now accused Lin Zhijian of violating copyright and plagiarizing state property.]. news.ltn.com.tw (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Retrieved 2024-05-04.

[28] "快訊／林智堅論文與竹科報告雷同涉侵權竹科管理局：將請中華大學說明 | ETtoday政治新聞 | ETtoday新聞雲" [Lin Zhijian's paper is similar to Zhu Ke's report, involving infringement]. www.ettoday.net (in Traditional Chinese). 2022-07-06. Retrieved 2024-05-04.

[29] "竹科管理局公文曝光！證實林智堅論文使用資料沒有申請授權" [Official documents from the Bamboo Management Bureau exposed! Confirmed that Lin Zhijian did not apply for authorization to use the materials in his thesis]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). 2022-07-21. Retrieved 2024-05-04.

[30] "林智堅中華大學碩論抄襲涉侵權　科管局：將釐清合約內容" [Lin Zhijian's master's degree thesis of China University was plagiarized and involved in infringement. The Science and Technology Administration: Will clarify the content of the contract]. Retrieved 2022-08-25.

[31] Lin, ZhiCheng. "竹科管理局告林智堅侵權國科會回應了" [Bamboo Management Bureau sues Lin Zhijian for infringement, National Science Council responds]. Retrieved 2023-02-05.

[32] 自由時報電子報 (2023-01-11). "陳明通︰林智堅論文抄襲案確定是冤案 - 政治 - 自由時報電子報". news.ltn.com.tw (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Retrieved 2024-05-02.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[16]

[17]

[18]

[19]

[20]

[21]

[22]

[23]

[24]

[25]

[26]

[27]

[28]

[29]

[30]

[31]

[32]

@@ Line 27: / Line 27: @@
 == Lin Zhijian responded ==
-Lin Zhijian responded that he participated in the bamboo science-commissioned research and also published a seminar paper with the same name as He Lixing and Wang Minglang<ref name=":3" /><ref name=":4">{{Cite web |title=她臉書貼王明郎教授聲明：林智堅研究合理 |trans-title=She posted a statement from Professor Wang Minglang on Facebook: Lin Zhijian’s research is reasonable |url=https://www.chinatimes.com/realtimenews/20220705002479-260407?chdtv |access-date=2022-07-05 |language=zh}}</ref>. [17] He thinks his behavior is not plagiarism, and He Lixing and Wang Minglang also issued a written statement to endorse him<ref name=":4" /><ref>{{Cite news |title=被控論文涉抄襲　林智堅急滅火：藍營炮製「林智堅版宇昌案」 我才是原創者！ |trans-title=Accused of plagiarism, Lin Zhijian urgently puts out the fire: Lanying concocted "Lin Zhijian's version of the Yuchang case" and I am the original author! |url=https://rwnews.tw/Article/Detail/4647 |language=zh}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |last=中央通訊社 |date=2022-07-05 |title=林智堅遭指論文涉抄襲 中午記者會說明【直播】 {{!}} 政治 |trans-title=Lin Zhijian was accused of plagiarism in his paper and explained at the noon press conference |url=https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aipl/202207055003.aspx |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=中央社 CNA |language=zh-Hant-TW}}</ref>,Wang Hongwei in the Chinese university to bamboo administration plan application; according to the plan application, architecture planning is responsible by Wang Mingming, investigation and analysis is by Wang Mingming and He Lixing is responsible for the report by Wang Mingming and Li Youzhi is responsible for writing, Lin Zhijian is an unpaid research assistant and is responsible for "assist in the investigation," so Wang Hongwei says that Lin Zhijian "just help send questionnaire" rather than the original, and points out that the bamboo final report cover host is "Dr. Li Youzhi, Dr. Wang Minglang," no Lin Zhijian<ref>{{Cite news |title=公開竹科研究計劃書「人力分工表」　王鴻薇：林智堅只是幫忙發問卷 |trans-title=Publication of Bamboo Research Plan "Manpower Division Table" Wang Hongwei: Lin Zhijian just helped distribute the questionnaire |url=https://www.storm.mg/article/4427113 |language=zh}}</ref>.
+Lin Zhijian responded that he participated in the bamboo science-commissioned research and also published a seminar paper with the same name as He Lixing and Wang Minglang<ref name=":3" /><ref name=":4">{{Cite web |title=她臉書貼王明郎教授聲明：林智堅研究合理 |trans-title=She posted a statement from Professor Wang Minglang on Facebook: Lin Zhijian’s research is reasonable |url=https://www.chinatimes.com/realtimenews/20220705002479-260407?chdtv |access-date=2022-07-05 |language=zh}}</ref>. [17] He thinks his behavior is not plagiarism, and He Lixing and Wang Minglang also issued a written statement to endorse him<ref name=":4" /><ref>{{Cite news |title=被控論文涉抄襲　林智堅急滅火：藍營炮製「林智堅版宇昌案」 我才是原創者！ |trans-title=Accused of plagiarism, Lin Zhijian urgently puts out the fire: Lanying concocted "Lin Zhijian's version of the Yuchang case" and I am the original author! |url=https://rwnews.tw/Article/Detail/4647 |language=zh}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |last=中央通訊社 |date=2022-07-05 |title=林智堅遭指論文涉抄襲 中午記者會說明【直播】 {{!}} 政治 |trans-title=Lin Zhijian was accused of plagiarism in his paper and explained at the noon press conference |url=https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aipl/202207055003.aspx |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=中央社 CNA |language=zh-Hant-TW}}</ref>,Wang Hongwei in the [[Chung Hua University|Chung Hua university]] to bamboo administration plan application; according to the plan application, architecture planning is responsible by Wang Mingming, investigation and analysis is by Wang Mingming and He Lixing is responsible for the report by Wang Mingming and Li Youzhi is responsible for writing, Lin Zhijian is an unpaid research assistant and is responsible for "assist in the investigation," so Wang Hongwei says that Lin Zhijian "just help send questionnaire" rather than the original, and points out that the bamboo final report cover host is "Dr. Li Youzhi, Dr. Wang Minglang," no Lin Zhijian<ref>{{Cite news |title=公開竹科研究計劃書「人力分工表」　王鴻薇：林智堅只是幫忙發問卷 |trans-title=Publication of Bamboo Research Plan "Manpower Division Table" Wang Hongwei: Lin Zhijian just helped distribute the questionnaire |url=https://www.storm.mg/article/4427113 |language=zh}}</ref>.
 On July 24, Lin Zhijian and lawmaker [[Cheng Yun-peng]] held a press conference, expressing in chronological order that his copyright ownership of the master's degree at the Discipline Management Institute of China is also his research process.
@@ Line 38: / Line 38: @@
 On August 24, [[Chung Hua University]] announced the results of the review, confirming that Lin Zhijian's plagiarism was a serious violation of academic ethics, revoked Lin Zhijian's master's degree, and also sent a letter to the National Library to remove Lin Zhijian's paper from the shelves<ref>{{Cite news |title=林智堅論文案 中華大學認定抄襲撤銷碩士學位 |trans-title=Lin Zhijian's dissertation, Chung Hwa University revoked master's degree after finding plagiarism |url=https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aipl/202208245003.aspx |access-date=2022-08-24}}</ref><ref>{{Cite news |title=林智堅論文案提訴願被駁回 審議委員：研究基礎能力不足 |trans-title=Lin Zhijian's petition for filing a paper was rejected. Review committee member: Insufficient basic research capabilities |url=https://www.taiwannews.com.tw/zh/news/4799483 |access-date=2023-02-03}}</ref>.According to the statement, He Lixing, the guiding professor of Lin Zhijian's thesis, and Li Youzhi, the member of the oral examination, are the co-host and the host of the plan, respectively, but do not investigate the final report of his master's thesis and the plan, which is obviously negligent, and will be sent to the teaching evaluation committee for review<ref>{{Cite web |title=林智堅碩士學位又沒了！中華大學也認定抄襲　校長發3點聲明籲記取教訓 |trans-title=Lin Zhijian’s master’s degree is gone again! Chung Hua University also identified plagiarism. The president issued a 3-point statement urging lessons to be learned. |url=https://rwnews.tw/article.php?news=4291 |access-date=2022-08-25 |language=zh}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |last=中央通訊社 |date=2022-08-24 |title=中華大學認定林智堅論文抄襲 指導教授賀力行與口委李友錚送教評會 {{!}} 政治 |trans-title=Chung Hwa University finds Lin Zhijian's paper plagiarized |url=https://www.cna.com.tw/news/aipl/202208240298.aspx |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=中央社 CNA |language=zh-Hant-TW}}</ref>.
-In early October, Lin filed a lawsuit with the Ministry of Education over the administrative action of [[Chung Hua University]] to revoke his degree.[31] After the trial of the lawsuit review committee, the Ministry of Education rejected the lawsuit filed by Lin Zhijian with the decision on January 19, 2023, of Taiwan Education Law (3) No. 1110094222, believing that Zhonghua University was punished in accordance with the regulations and the cancellation of Lin Zhijian's master's degree was not wrong<ref>{{Cite web |last=聯合新聞網 |title=林智堅學位被撤首場訴願遭駁回 教部提一點可再拚翻盤 |trans-title=Lin Zhijian's first appeal against having his degree revoked was rejected. The Ministry of Education can make a comeback with some suggestions |url=https://udn.com/news/story/6885/6945348 |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=聯合新聞網 |language=zh-Hant-TW}}</ref>.Lin Zhijian also apologized on his personal [[Facebook]] fan page on February 14, 2023, for revoking the punishment of Zhonghua University, respecting the resolution of the Litigation Review Committee of the Ministry of [[Education]], and not filing an administrative lawsuit<ref>{{Cite web |last=聯合新聞網 |title=道歉了！林智堅撤回台大學位訴願案 教育部證實「結案」 |trans-title=Apologized! Lin Zhijian withdraws appeal for National Taiwan University degree |url=https://udn.com/news/story/6885/6971508 |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=聯合新聞網 |language=zh-Hant-TW}}</ref><ref>{{Cite news |last=Wang |first=BoWen |title=放棄戰清白！林智堅道歉「論文寫作有瑕疵」：撤回台大學位訴願 |trans-title=Give up the fight for innocence! Lin Zhijian apologizes for "flaws in thesis writing": appeals to withdraw his degree from National Taiwan University |url=https://www.chinatimes.com/realtimenews/20230214005268-260407?chdtv}}</ref>.
+In early October, Lin filed a lawsuit with the Ministry of Education over the administrative action of [[Chung Hua University]] to revoke his degree.[31] After the trial of the lawsuit review committee, the Ministry of Education rejected the lawsuit filed by Lin Zhijian with the decision on January 19, 2023, of Taiwan Education Law (3) No. 1110094222, believing that [[Chung Hua University]] was punished in accordance with the regulations and the cancellation of Lin Zhijian's master's degree was not wrong<ref>{{Cite web |last=聯合新聞網 |title=林智堅學位被撤首場訴願遭駁回 教部提一點可再拚翻盤 |trans-title=Lin Zhijian's first appeal against having his degree revoked was rejected. The Ministry of Education can make a comeback with some suggestions |url=https://udn.com/news/story/6885/6945348 |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=聯合新聞網 |language=zh-Hant-TW}}</ref>.Lin Zhijian also apologized on his personal [[Facebook]] fan page on February 14, 2023, for revoking the punishment of Zhonghua University, respecting the resolution of the Litigation Review Committee of the Ministry of [[Education]], and not filing an administrative lawsuit<ref>{{Cite web |last=聯合新聞網 |title=道歉了！林智堅撤回台大學位訴願案 教育部證實「結案」 |trans-title=Apologized! Lin Zhijian withdraws appeal for National Taiwan University degree |url=https://udn.com/news/story/6885/6971508 |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=聯合新聞網 |language=zh-Hant-TW}}</ref><ref>{{Cite news |last=Wang |first=BoWen |title=放棄戰清白！林智堅道歉「論文寫作有瑕疵」：撤回台大學位訴願 |trans-title=Give up the fight for innocence! Lin Zhijian apologizes for "flaws in thesis writing": appeals to withdraw his degree from National Taiwan University |url=https://www.chinatimes.com/realtimenews/20230214005268-260407?chdtv}}</ref>.
-== Copyright problem ==
+=== Copyright problem ===
-Ling Tao and Yang Zhi-dou, a KMT Taipei city councilor candidate, went to the Taipei District People's Office on July 6 to accuse Lin Zhijian of violating the Copyright Law<ref>{{Cite web |date=2022-07-06 |title=林智堅論文再爆抄月刊 藍告違著作權法 |trans-title=Lin Zhijian's article was plagiarized from a monthly magazine again, and he was accused of violating copyright law |url=https://tw.news.yahoo.com/%E6%9E%97%E6%99%BA%E5%A0%85%E8%AB%96%E6%96%87%E5%86%8D%E7%88%86%E6%8A%84%E6%9C%88%E5%88%8A-%E8%97%8D%E5%91%8A%E9%81%95%E8%91%97%E4%BD%9C%E6%AC%8A%E6%B3%95-044504806.html |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=Yahoo News |language=zh-Hant-TW}}</ref>. Wang also accused the Taipei District Prosecutor's Office of Lin, his professors, and others of violating the copyright law<ref>{{Cite web |last=自由時報電子報 |date=2022-07-07 |title=王鴻薇挨告加重誹謗 今告發林智堅違反著作權、剽竊國家財產 - 政治 - 自由時報電子報 |trans-title=Wang Hongwei was sued for aggravated defamation and now accused Lin Zhijian of violating copyright and plagiarizing state property. |url=https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/politics/breakingnews/3984079 |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=news.ltn.com.tw |language=zh-TW}}</ref>.
+Ling Tao and Yang Zhi-dou, a KMT Taipei city councilor candidate, went to the [[Taipei]] District People's Office on July 6 to accuse Lin Zhijian of violating the Copyright Law<ref>{{Cite web |date=2022-07-06 |title=林智堅論文再爆抄月刊 藍告違著作權法 |trans-title=Lin Zhijian's article was plagiarized from a monthly magazine again, and he was accused of violating copyright law |url=https://tw.news.yahoo.com/%E6%9E%97%E6%99%BA%E5%A0%85%E8%AB%96%E6%96%87%E5%86%8D%E7%88%86%E6%8A%84%E6%9C%88%E5%88%8A-%E8%97%8D%E5%91%8A%E9%81%95%E8%91%97%E4%BD%9C%E6%AC%8A%E6%B3%95-044504806.html |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=Yahoo News |language=zh-Hant-TW}}</ref>. Wang also accused the Taipei District Prosecutor's Office of Lin, his professors, and others of violating the [[copyright]] law<ref>{{Cite web |last=自由時報電子報 |date=2022-07-07 |title=王鴻薇挨告加重誹謗 今告發林智堅違反著作權、剽竊國家財產 - 政治 - 自由時報電子報 |trans-title=Wang Hongwei was sued for aggravated defamation and now accused Lin Zhijian of violating copyright and plagiarizing state property. |url=https://news.ltn.com.tw/news/politics/breakingnews/3984079 |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=news.ltn.com.tw |language=zh-TW}}</ref>.
-According to the contract between the [[Hsinchu Science Park]] Administration and [[Chung Hua University]], the property rights of the works in the closing report belong to the Bamboo Science Administration. In a statement, the bureau, on the evening of July 6, asked [[Chung Hua University]] to make an explanation<ref>{{Cite web |last= |date=2022-07-06 |title=快訊／林智堅論文與竹科報告雷同涉侵權 竹科管理局：將請中華大學說明 {{!}} ETtoday政治新聞 {{!}} ETtoday新聞雲 |trans-title=Lin Zhijian's paper is similar to Zhu Ke's report, involving infringement |url=https://www.ettoday.net/news/20220706/2288659.htm |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=www.ettoday.net |language=zh-Hant}}</ref>.The administration has also publicly stated that no one has applied for authorization to use the closing report<ref>{{Cite web |date=2022-07-21 |title=竹科管理局公文曝光！證實林智堅論文使用資料沒有申請授權 |trans-title=Official documents from the Bamboo Management Bureau exposed! Confirmed that Lin Zhijian did not apply for authorization to use the materials in his thesis |url=https://tw.news.yahoo.com/%E7%AB%B9%E7%A7%91%E7%AE%A1%E7%90%86%E5%B1%80%E5%85%AC%E6%96%87%E6%9B%9D%E5%85%89-%E8%AD%89%E5%AF%A6%E6%9E%97%E6%99%BA%E5%A0%85%E8%AB%96%E6%96%87%E4%BD%BF%E7%94%A8%E8%B3%87%E6%96%99%E6%B2%92%E6%9C%89%E7%94%B3%E8%AB%8B%E6%8E%88%E6%AC%8A-123014737.html |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=Yahoo News |language=zh-Hant-TW}}</ref>.Bamboo Science Administration Bureau and Zhonghua University have exchanged many official letters and discussions<ref>{{Cite web |title=林智堅中華大學碩論抄襲涉侵權　科管局：將釐清合約內容 |trans-title=Lin Zhijian's master's degree thesis of China University was plagiarized and involved in infringement. The Science and Technology Administration: Will clarify the content of the contract |url=https://rwnews.tw/article.php?news=4301 |access-date=2022-08-25}}</ref>.On December 30, 2022, the bureau filed a civil lawsuit against Lin Zhijian for violation of the Copyright Law and filed a criminal complaint to the Hsinchu Local Procuratorate in Taiwan on January 3, 2023<ref>{{Cite web |last=Lin |first=ZhiCheng |title=竹科管理局告林智堅侵權 國科會回應了 |trans-title=Bamboo Management Bureau sues Lin Zhijian for infringement, National Science Council responds |url=https://www.chinatimes.com/realtimenews/20230205001685-260405?chdtv |access-date=2023-02-05}}</ref>.
+According to the contract between the [[Hsinchu Science Park]] Administration and [[Chung Hua University]], the property rights of the works in the closing report belong to the Bamboo Science Administration. In a statement, the bureau, on the evening of July 6, asked [[Chung Hua University]] to make an explanation<ref>{{Cite web |last= |date=2022-07-06 |title=快訊／林智堅論文與竹科報告雷同涉侵權 竹科管理局：將請中華大學說明 {{!}} ETtoday政治新聞 {{!}} ETtoday新聞雲 |trans-title=Lin Zhijian's paper is similar to Zhu Ke's report, involving infringement |url=https://www.ettoday.net/news/20220706/2288659.htm |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=www.ettoday.net |language=zh-Hant}}</ref>.The administration has also publicly stated that no one has applied for authorization to use the closing report<ref>{{Cite web |date=2022-07-21 |title=竹科管理局公文曝光！證實林智堅論文使用資料沒有申請授權 |trans-title=Official documents from the Bamboo Management Bureau exposed! Confirmed that Lin Zhijian did not apply for authorization to use the materials in his thesis |url=https://tw.news.yahoo.com/%E7%AB%B9%E7%A7%91%E7%AE%A1%E7%90%86%E5%B1%80%E5%85%AC%E6%96%87%E6%9B%9D%E5%85%89-%E8%AD%89%E5%AF%A6%E6%9E%97%E6%99%BA%E5%A0%85%E8%AB%96%E6%96%87%E4%BD%BF%E7%94%A8%E8%B3%87%E6%96%99%E6%B2%92%E6%9C%89%E7%94%B3%E8%AB%8B%E6%8E%88%E6%AC%8A-123014737.html |access-date=2024-05-04 |website=Yahoo News |language=zh-Hant-TW}}</ref>.Bamboo Science Administration Bureau and Zhonghua University have exchanged many official letters and discussions<ref>{{Cite web |title=林智堅中華大學碩論抄襲涉侵權　科管局：將釐清合約內容 |trans-title=Lin Zhijian's master's degree thesis of China University was plagiarized and involved in infringement. The Science and Technology Administration: Will clarify the content of the contract |url=https://rwnews.tw/article.php?news=4301 |access-date=2022-08-25}}</ref>.On December 30, 2022, the bureau filed a civil lawsuit against Lin Zhijian for violation of the [[Copyright]] Law and filed a criminal complaint to the Hsinchu Local Procuratorate in Taiwan on January 3, 2023<ref>{{Cite web |last=Lin |first=ZhiCheng |title=竹科管理局告林智堅侵權 國科會回應了 |trans-title=Bamboo Management Bureau sues Lin Zhijian for infringement, National Science Council responds |url=https://www.chinatimes.com/realtimenews/20230205001685-260405?chdtv |access-date=2023-02-05}}</ref>.
 == National Taiwan University thesis ==