Cannabis Ruderalis

Top edits to an article All edits made to a page by one user, in chronological order.

Article Wikipedia talk:Good article nominations (Log · Page History)
Хэрэглэгч Geometry guy (Edit Counter· Top Edits)
Total edits 586
Minor edits 40 (6.8%)
(Semi-)automated edits 4 (0.7%)
Reverted edits 4 (0.7%)
atbe1 4.4
Нэмж оруулсан (байт)2 356,313
Deleted (bytes) -3,515
Minor edits · 40 (6.8%)
Major edits · 546 (93.2%)
(Semi-)automated edits · 4 (0.7%)
Manual edits · 582 (99.3%)
Reverted edits · 4 (0.7%)
Unreverted edits · 582 (99.3%)
1 Average time between edits (days)
2 Added text is any positive addition that wasn't reverted (approximate)
Date Links Хэмжээ Edit summary
Diff · Түүх 1,226 Another solution? Co-nominations: Amplify idea and potential benefits
Diff · Түүх 369 Another solution? Co-nominations: r
Diff · Түүх 0 Oppose: fix numbering
Diff · Түүх 558 Oppose: Not in spirit of GA: suggest alternative below: co-nominations
Diff · Түүх 282 Another solution? Co-nominations: r
Diff · Түүх 1,994 Another solution? Co-nominations: new section
Diff · Түүх 626 Renomination of failed GA with no changes: Failing without a hold is an option that should be used more widely in preference to quickfails
Diff · Түүх 242 Harvard citations: Thanks and comment
Diff · Түүх 205 Some problems after Chris G's change: GAN error issue
Diff · Түүх 135 Renomination of failed GA with no changes: Great - watchlisted
Diff · Түүх 1,179 Renomination of failed GA with no changes: With tears in my eyes, options for GA, and this article
Diff · Түүх 510 Category Splitting: Comment
Diff · Түүх -298 RFC to make FA leaders elected, not appointed: rm
Diff · Түүх 450 RfC: Proposal to limit excessive GA nominations: Reply to Aircorn
Diff · Түүх 1,109 RfC: Proposal to limit excessive GA nominations: Oppose limits on nominations, obviously, and reply to Imzadi, Czarkoff
Diff · Түүх 401 30 day limit proposal: Great idea
Diff · Түүх 328 30 day limit proposal: Not just needing clarification, but completely wrong-headed
Diff · Түүх 262 30 day limit proposal: Bad law makes for bad implementation
Diff · Түүх 49 Jerem43's reviews: Hard cases make bad law
Diff · Түүх 326 Jerem43's reviews: Er, what?
Diff · Түүх 1,817 Is suggestion (review Artcile X by editor A, and he may return the favor by reviewing your article) ok?: It isn't about appearances, but good reviewing
Diff · Түүх 2 Withdrawing nominations:
Diff · Түүх 339 Withdrawing nominations: Add reminder of GA no-buro principle
Diff · Түүх 154 Withdrawing nominations: Done
Diff · Түүх 913 Withdrawing nominations: new section
Diff · Түүх 246 Reviewing templates: Reply to WAID
Diff · Түүх 9 Reviewing templates:
Diff · Түүх 294 Reviewing templates: Replies to WAID
Diff · Түүх 109 Tony Blair: Hopefully resolved
Diff · Түүх 234 Renaming an article while undergoing GA process: Reply
Diff · Түүх 1,060 Picture licensing question: Reply
Diff · Түүх 161 How to classify a medieval fair?: Suggestion
Diff · Түүх 737 Wrongly failed GA's: Use GAR, but make clear that your preferred outcome is restoring the nomination
Diff · Түүх 271 On a GAN being a candidate for merging: Fixed
Diff · Түүх 783 On a GAN being a candidate for merging: reply
Diff · Түүх 192 GAN Statistic: Reply
Diff · Түүх 389 Bot glitch: Now fixed, and how to avoid this in future
Diff · Түүх 424 Bot glitch: Back "on hold", problem recurs.
Diff · Түүх -97 Bot glitch: Still not fixed
Diff · Түүх 260 Bot glitch: Update reply to Wizardman
Diff · Түүх 551 Bot glitch: Reply to Wizardman
Diff · Түүх 438 GAN Statistic: Suggested location
Diff · Түүх 404 Bot glitch: Bot is adding a blank line
Diff · Түүх 698 Bot glitch: Possible causes
Diff · Түүх 550 Abandoned GAR: Fixed - suggested process
Diff · Түүх 398 Clarification please?: Template name is historical, article history is more clear
Diff · Түүх 455 Karma system: Data can be helpful, but can also be misused
Diff · Түүх 153 Taking over a GA review: Thanks for reporting it here
Diff · Түүх 782 Karma system: GA depends upon its integrity and goal: to list precisely those articles which meet the GA criteria
Diff · Түүх 622 Good article nominations: Two comments
Diff · Түүх 458 Feedback/reevaluation of the GA bot automation of WP:GAN: Comment on reevaluation
Diff · Түүх 906 Feedback/reevaluation of the GA bot automation of WP:GAN: new section
Diff · Түүх 1,281 10,000 GAs: a time to celebrate and refocus on our mission: new section
Diff · Түүх 441 Time to limit nominations: And this is the wrong time to decide so
Diff · Түүх 104 StatisticianBot back up and running: Thanks you again
Diff · Түүх 946 Are IPs allowed to nominate articles?: Disentangle complicated story
Diff · Түүх 2,673 Proposal to change the broadness criteria: Long comment
Diff · Түүх 304 Since this is automated: Done long ago: here's the link
Diff · Түүх 281 Editors are still doing things manually: Comment
Diff · Түүх 403 Glitch on the project page: Precedent
Diff · Түүх 345 New bot and Template:ArticleHistory: Good question, partial answer
Diff · Түүх 445 Operation Paula: Heads up
Diff · Түүх 356 Operation Paula: Not nominated - try again
Diff · Түүх 278 automated GAN updates: Availability
Diff · Түүх 287 automated GAN updates: Suggest start date/time
Diff · Түүх 725 automated GAN updates: Propose live trial
Diff · Түүх 39,224 Reverted edits by Geometry guy (talk) to last version by Edge3
Diff · Түүх -39,814 (reverted)  Propose live trial
Diff · Түүх 590 automated GAN updates: Propose live trial
Diff · Түүх 157 Page numbers for magazine articles: Added lines at WP:GACN
Diff · Түүх 721 Page numbers for magazine articles: Comment based on GA criteria
Diff · Түүх 1,261 Backlog = cap?: Comments on this topic and proposal
Diff · Түүх 1,079 Section break: Relative status of various pages
Diff · Түүх 587 Section break: Ideas so far
Diff · Түүх 1,310 Approval from GA Director: Two replies
Diff · Түүх 1,017 Approval from GA Director: Reply re GA-Class
Diff · Түүх 1,049 Approval from GA Director: Replies in 3 places
Diff · Түүх 1,458 Approval from GA Director: Agree with two ideas
Diff · Түүх 1,336 Approval from GA Director: Explanations of processes and comments
Diff · Түүх 642 GAN backlog drive: Another motivation: 10000 GAs
Diff · Түүх 41 Add archive box link
Diff · Түүх 189 Ann Romney nomination reopened without prejudice
Diff · Түүх 475 GAR for September 11 attacks: new section
Diff · Түүх 1,010 Community GAR reminder: new section
Diff · Түүх 138 Frequently Asked Questions infobox: Updated
Diff · Түүх 429 Review closing bot: Reply To Xtzou
Diff · Түүх 1,504 Review closing bot: Remarks and a question about automating WP:GAN
Diff · Түүх 170 Review requested: Done and thanks
Diff · Түүх 14 Collapse FAQ as reviewers primarily need to get to the TOC easily
Diff · Түүх 405 WP:Good article reassessment/Paparazzi (Lady Gaga song)/2: new section
Diff · Түүх 115 Troubling trend?: WP:RGA
Diff · Түүх 519 Criterion 2b: Comment
Diff · Түүх 1,678 Criterion 2b: Comment
Diff · Түүх 1,398 Is this an article or a list?: eligibility vs passableness
Diff · Түүх 495 Is this an article or list?: Quote
Diff · Түүх 1,143 Is this an article or list?: Reply to dabomb
Diff · Түүх 226 Some strange GA reviews: PS to request
Diff · Түүх 403 Some strange GA reviews: Fixes, and request to check I Miss You (Miley Cyrus song); review page Talk:I Miss You (Miley Cyrus song)/GA1
Diff · Түүх 273 Some strange GA reviews: What you do have to check
Diff · Түүх 313 Report bot: GAN/Status
Diff · Түүх 7 Some strange GA reviews: Brad Follmer returned to the nominations list and the review moved to /GA1/archive
Diff · Түүх 645 Some strange GA reviews: Concur plus comments
Diff · Түүх 423 Comment on new subtopics and current GAs
Diff · Түүх 133 GA Review transcluding multiple times: Blocked
Diff · Түүх 905 Bot is almost there: Page to watchlist and comment on
Diff · Түүх 223 Reviewer instructions on review page's edit box: Will do
Diff · Түүх 815 Things that still need to be accomplished: Comment
Diff · Түүх 1 Post-automation guidelines draft: Typo
Diff · Түүх 1,073 Post-automation guidelines draft: Support and flexibility for reviewers is the key
Diff · Түүх 581 Premature GAN: Comment
Diff · Түүх 629 Automatic listing of nominees at WP:GAN: Suggest a back-up operation
Diff · Түүх 200 Further issues: That would help - good luck with the challenge!
Diff · Түүх 514 Automatic listing of nominees at WP:GAN: Comment on templates
Diff · Түүх 364 Review by consensus: We don't need more of this, we need less of this
Diff · Түүх 1,141 Further issues: Edit summaries
Diff · Түүх 90 Green boxes: Agree with Diderot's dreams
Diff · Түүх 489 Automatic listing of nominees at WP:GAN: Trim comment and start subsection on other issues
Diff · Түүх 2,203 Automatic listing of nominees at WP:GAN: Replies
Diff · Түүх 268 another major issue with automated the GAN page: Different issue but would also be helpful
Diff · Түүх 621 Green boxes: Agree
Diff · Түүх 1,912 Automatic listing of nominees at WP:GAN: Replies to Dr. Cash
Diff · Түүх 322 Automatic listing of nominees at WP:GAN: Comment
Diff · Түүх 983 Automatic listing of nominees at WP:GAN: Reply
Diff · Түүх 0 Update archive number
Diff · Түүх 998 Review by consensus: Comments
Diff · Түүх 805 Retitle and reply
Diff · Түүх 1,530 Bot is ready to take over: Further comments and issues
Diff · Түүх 763 Bot is ready to take over: Replies
Diff · Түүх 648 Bot is ready to take over: Benefit worth the effort
Diff · Түүх 173 Bot is ready to take over: Reply
Diff · Түүх 893 Review by consensus: 2.5 million articles are still crap; we need to fix them, not more bureaucracy
Diff · Түүх 574 Something to bring up when we reconsider putting the GA sign on article pages: Comment
Diff · Түүх 34 Link to new archive
Diff · Түүх 975 Bot is ready to take over: Comments
Diff · Түүх 636 Order of reviewing articles: Reply
Diff · Түүх 434 Order of reviewing articles: Encouraging editors who work on older nominations
Diff · Түүх 693 Neutral title and reply
Diff · Түүх 696 Question about recent quick fail: Looks like the workings of the anti-Pastafarian cabal to me
Diff · Түүх 173 Enforcement of seven day grace periods of articles on hold: FAQ would indeed help
Diff · Түүх 162 Proposal: Consensus
Diff · Түүх 156 Nomination restrictions: Refer to FAQ :
Diff · Түүх 133 Nomination restrictions: With what benefit?
Diff · Түүх 186 Nomination restrictions: Evidence please
Diff · Түүх 184 Nomination restrictions: May be a good idea; wikilink suitable page
Diff · Түүх 2,177 Nomination restrictions: Standard reasons and explanations
Diff · Түүх -85 Question on procedure, and perhaps templates: Fix double sig typo
Diff · Түүх 1,096 Any registered editor?: Summary: excellent advice above on when to ignore the rules
Diff · Түүх 1,705 Question - Theatre: Current set-up and general replies
Diff · Түүх 159 Question - Theatre: Problem?
Diff · Түүх 674 How short may a GA be?: Suggestions on TNA Legends Championship
Diff · Түүх 217 I agree. Move along please...
Diff · Түүх 322 milestone reached: Reply to Dr C
Diff · Түүх 207 milestone reached: Point of fact
Diff · Түүх 509 milestone reached: WP:GA/S
Diff · Түүх 887 milestone reached: Comments
Diff · Түүх 210 Reviewing guidelines: new section
Diff · Түүх 509 protection and stability.: Comment
Diff · Түүх 963 GA Process: Explain role of GA and its motivations
Diff · Түүх 190 GA1 template: If there is demand
Diff · Түүх 86 Any mathematicians about?: No probs
Diff · Түүх 424 Get on Your Boots withdrawing: Advantage of ArticleHistory
Diff · Түүх 426 Stability of section headings: new section
Diff · Түүх 786 Any reason why the peer review bot isn't reviewing GAN?: Comment
Diff · Түүх 187 Sweeps running gag :
Diff · Түүх 146 Content noticeboard: Not much
Diff · Түүх 1,085 Focus on main issues and provide some resources
Diff · Түүх 1,003 Can non-contributors to an article nominate it for GAN?: Improving the encyclopedia
Diff · Түүх 131 Can non-contributors to an article nominate it for GAN?: Strong point
Diff · Түүх 386 Homosexual transsexual: Reply
Diff · Түүх 1,444 Can non-contributors to an article nominate it for GAN?: Yes
Diff · Түүх 1,253 Homosexual transsexual: Suggestion
Diff · Түүх 301 Good articles which are found wanting at FAC: new section
Diff · Түүх 362 Reassessment: point of GAN
Diff · Түүх -176 Oops my bad
Diff · Түүх 176 (reverted)  Fatbeard (South Park): GAN
Diff · Түүх 310 7 minute review: Comment on GAR
Diff · Түүх 86 An underused resource: No worries
Diff · Түүх 109 An underused resource: Transclusion
Diff · Түүх 243 An underused resource: Go for it
Diff · Түүх 493 An underused resource: new section
Diff · Түүх 166 What has happened with GA reviewing?: Pride for high quality reviews
Diff · Түүх 812 California Proposition 8 (2008): Link to similar recent case and similar solution
Diff · Түүх 44 New archive needed
Diff · Түүх 1,126 Chicago bid for the 2016 Summer Olympics: Comments and suggestion
Diff · Түүх 635 Quality of reviews: One review is not the end of the story
Diff · Түүх 240 Reviewing articles that you've reviewed before: Fine, the main issue is significant prior contribution to the article
Diff · Түүх -1,055 I said, enough
Diff · Түүх 1,055 (reverted)  Reverted edits by Geometry guy (talk) to last version by Pyrotec
Diff · Түүх -1,055 (reverted)  Undid revision 277528672 by Pyrotec (talk)
Diff · Түүх 1,009 Using inappropriate criteria for quick fail reviews: Enough
Diff · Түүх 483 What should I do if an article I'm reviewing doesn't satisfy notability?: Reply
Diff · Түүх 1,143 Curious:
Diff · Түүх 178 Asking advice for GA category: Look to WP:GA
Diff · Түүх 324 Proposal to merge GAN & PR: Comment
Diff · Түүх 168 Wikipedia:Good article reassessment/Ruth Martin (Lassie)/1: Community reassessment - comments appreciated
Diff · Түүх 164 Being "broad", even when there are no references: a copy of raw data is still a primary source
Diff · Түүх 1,428 Being "broad", even when there are no references: Comment and address real issue
Diff · Түүх 345 Kohlberg Kravis Roberts: Suggest individual reassessment
Diff · Түүх 608 Kohlberg Kravis Roberts: Agree
Diff · Түүх 192 award for backlog cleaning:
Diff · Түүх 383 Is this a list?: "Should this be a list" is actually a better question
Diff · Түүх 615 Slow/unresponsive reviewer: Timescales
Diff · Түүх 178 Subst error with a GAR subpage?:
Diff · Түүх 1 Subst error with a GAR subpage?:
Diff · Түүх 186 Subst error with a GAR subpage?: Transclusion onto talk page may have been the problem
Diff · Түүх 213 Subst error with a GAR subpage?: Comment
Diff · Түүх 229 This process is broken: Add point of information
Diff · Түүх 612 This process is broken: Please slow down
Diff · Түүх 0 Break: Serious thought needed (typo)
Diff · Түүх 392 Break: Serious thought needed
Diff · Түүх 3,092 Break: Add to copy
Diff · Түүх 249 Problematic review: Please provide links, thanks
Diff · Түүх 950 Problematic review: Three short comments
Diff · Түүх 608 Problematic review: Replies
Diff · Түүх 13 How to handle the cricket nominations?: My own comment was unclear
Diff · Түүх 212 How to handle the cricket nominations?: Been meaning to comment on this, but too busy! SFB has the clearest answer for JRP!
Diff · Түүх 3 Problematic review:
Diff · Түүх 58 Problematic review:
Diff · Түүх 1,161 Problematic review: Then we need a proper review
Diff · Түүх 1,669 Is there a limit to how many noms you have?: Replies
Diff · Түүх 1,143 Question about offering tit for tat incentive: Helping the helpful is part of collegiate editing, but tit for tat is dangerous ground
Diff · Түүх 206 Just playing Devil's advocate: Best practice like this needs to encourage others
Diff · Түүх 608 Just playing Devil's advocate: When you are the lead reviewer, it is your call
Diff · Түүх 170 Just playing Devil's advocate: Even if it doesn't happen, there is no harm in encouraging it
Diff · Түүх 942 WP:Notability (fiction): Issue
Diff · Түүх 700 Just playing Devil's advocate: This is a nice idea in the context of open review
Diff · Түүх 639 WP:Notability (fiction): new section
Diff · Түүх 289 Mac OS X: Concise comment
Diff · Түүх 783 Question on comprehensiveness: Reply
Diff · Түүх 621 Question on comprehensiveness: This is a serious issue
Diff · Түүх 610 Question on comprehensiveness: WP:BLP
Diff · Түүх 1,661 Is there a limit to how many times this thread crops up?: Number of articles at GAN is irrelevant - indeed it provides reviewers with more choice - need to encourage more nominators to review
Diff · Түүх 282 GA guides: Links
Diff · Түүх 829 Articles where sources are in foreign language: Failing without a hold, but with a review should be encouraged
Diff · Түүх 885 Articles where sources are in foreign language: Comment
Diff · Түүх 188 Articles where sources are in foreign language: cf Ukraine and Slovakia
Diff · Түүх -7 Articles where sources are in foreign language: cf Prussia
Diff · Түүх 291 Articles where sources are in foreign language: cf Prussia
Diff · Түүх 950 Articles where sources are in foreign language: Anacronisms
Diff · Түүх 88 GA review not updating on article Talk page: WP:PURGE would be the usual answer
Diff · Түүх 1,313 As a review: Comment on reviewer levels and flexibility
Diff · Түүх 1,778 Poor quality articles:
Diff · Түүх 756 Poor quality articles: Reply
Diff · Түүх 703 Poor quality articles: Comment
Diff · Түүх 546 Request re section titles
Diff · Түүх 826 Drive-by fail: Simpler solution
Diff · Түүх 903 Drive by promotion of Zarqa River: Reply
Diff · Түүх 288 Drive-by nomination:
Diff · Түүх 356 Drive-by nomination: Reply
Diff · Түүх 889 Drive-by nomination: Done, but add general comment on quick-failing, administrative removal and failing without a hold
Diff · Түүх 580 Biology and medicine: Explain levels
Diff · Түүх 1,527 Criticism, not review: Confusion, query, and comment
Diff · Түүх 756 Biology and medicine: Reply and comment
Diff · Түүх 295 Model GA reviews: Request for more
Diff · Түүх 462 Model GA reviews: new section
Diff · Түүх 153 Question on how to disengage: Welcome, as responses demonstrate
Diff · Түүх 903 Quid pro quo and backlog: Comments
Diff · Түүх 211 Closing of nomination page: Set-up
Diff · Түүх 304 Quid pro quo and backlog: Agree
Diff · Түүх 360 Closing of nomination page: Comment
Diff · Түүх 250 GA and peer review: Fine
Diff · Түүх 476 GAN reviewer of the month, graph and comment
Diff · Түүх 949 Support: Support with comments
Diff · Түүх 399 Neutral: Comment
Diff · Түүх 304 Questions: Those cases were not typical
Diff · Түүх 246 Will add my own views in due course
Diff · Түүх 544 Questions: GAR can cope
Diff · Түүх 470 Neutral: Comment on reviewer numbers
Diff · Түүх 446 Oppose: Comment: I think this actually reduces instruction creep
Diff · Түүх 217 Please help with the ASCB workshop: What can we do to help?
Diff · Түүх 978 Plagiarism and reliable sources: new section
Diff · Түүх 52 new archive started; restructure slightly; 7->10d archiving
Diff · Түүх 0 A broken process?: Sigh, I should know how to sigh
Diff · Түүх 586 A broken process?: Nostalgia and elimination drives
Diff · Түүх 141 Please help with the ASCB workshop: UTC
Diff · Түүх 615 Limiting nominations?: Statistics
Diff · Түүх 118 Please help with the ASCB workshop: Count me in. UTC times would be helpful
Diff · Түүх 180 Community GAR reminder: Pretty please, and maybe alternative meaning of GAR would not meet with universal approval :
Diff · Түүх 167 User:Dr pda/Good article statistics: Reply
Diff · Түүх 301 Rejecting an article on its subject not merit: Community reassessment opened
Diff · Түүх 1,094 Community GAR reminder: new section
Diff · Түүх 367 Apologies for disruption to GAN subpages; normal service now resumed: Reply
Diff · Түүх 1,169 Apologies for disruption to GAN subpages; normal service now resumed: new section
Diff · Түүх 563 Rule to make only established editors review for GA status?: Nothing to see here :
Diff · Түүх 1,401 Rejecting an article on its subject not merit: I fail to see any signs of instability and not reviewing it goes against basic GA principles and considerable precedent
Diff · Түүх 215 Pressure of work: Reply
Diff · Түүх 70 Backlog update: Add
Diff · Түүх 149 Backlog update:
Diff · Түүх 545 Backlog update: new section
Diff · Түүх 255 Moving up nominations: New (albeit experimental) resource
Diff · Түүх 161 Withdraw a GAN - how to handle - Talk:Article/GA1: Agree
Diff · Түүх 200 Icons!: Confuses WikiProject ratings and community assessments
Diff · Түүх 2 Larry O'Brien Championship Trophy: Fix link to featured topic criteria
Diff · Түүх 5 Larry O'Brien Championship Trophy: copyedit replies
Diff · Түүх 492 Larry O'Brien Championship Trophy: Broadness and structural weaknesses
Diff · Түүх 423 Larry O'Brien Championship Trophy: The FTC need to be fixed methinks
Diff · Түүх 1,133 Larry O'Brien Championship Trophy: Merge or even nominate for deletion!
Diff · Түүх 1,194 GAN - GA links
Diff · Түүх 302 Citation styles - MoS question: Beautifully formatted unreliable sources do not a GA make
Diff · Түүх 325 Links and reports: Well spotted
Diff · Түүх 365 Time for a purge: Provide member info from cats
Diff · Түүх 308 Time for a purge: Try asking Giggy
Diff · Түүх 379 Time for a purge: Advertising needed
Diff · Түүх 201 Review Page: Testing
Diff · Түүх 180 Review Page: Links added (new reviews only)
Diff · Түүх 1,273 Time for a purge: Comments and graph
Diff · Түүх 88 Strange transclusion problem: WP:PURGE
Diff · Түүх 186 Time for a purge: Link to previous drives
Diff · Түүх 429 "Featured short articles": Proposal added to encourage cross-process thinking
Diff · Түүх 218 GA review of Horse: Comment
Diff · Түүх 191 Confusing redirect question: Comment
Diff · Түүх 90 Confusing redirect question: Fixed
Diff · Түүх 164 5000 GAs! Congratulations to all
Diff · Түүх 402 A-Class: No hey banda
Diff · Түүх 362 0.7 DVD: Oh ye of little faith :
Diff · Түүх 538 0.7 DVD: Please help if you can
Diff · Түүх 834 Information is always a good thing, so I've updated the graphs :
Diff · Түүх 566 Reformatting GA comments on talk page: EC
Diff · Түүх 580 Help!: Reviewers have different styles; plus mention Template:GATable
Diff · Түүх 802 Reformatting GA comments on talk page: Issues and fixes: are there other examples?
Diff · Түүх 446 Screw up article talk page: All help with instructions is most welcome
Diff · Түүх 315 Screw up article talk page: Fixed, but are the instructions clear enough?
Diff · Түүх 428 GA review pages: Thought of that - comments?
Diff · Түүх 765 GA review pages: Comments
Diff · Түүх 1,518 Individual reassessment: new section
Diff · Түүх 469 Unappropriate delist: Comment on changes in process
Diff · Түүх 443 Backlog under 100: Good work, and request for help at WP:GAR
Diff · Түүх 323 Stuck between a rock and an en-dash: Another clue :
Diff · Түүх 453 Stuck between a rock and an en-dash: Attention folks... :
Diff · Түүх 243 Stuck between a rock and an en-dash: Coward! :
Diff · Түүх 203 GAN for 4X: Moved comments
Diff · Түүх 53 New archive and improve format
Diff · Түүх 774 How long is the backlog, typically?: Replies
Diff · Түүх 463 How long is the backlog, typically?: Float right updated backlog, and comment
Diff · Түүх 446 How long is the backlog, typically?: Don't see the point of GAN directors
Diff · Түүх 331 How long is the backlog, typically?: Something to watchlist
Diff · Түүх 347 Article history: Don't waste time with oldids
Diff · Түүх 126 Article history: Subpage system should help
Diff · Түүх 429 Article history: Yes, or maybe no
Diff · Түүх 313 New system: Clarifications always welcome
Diff · Түүх 96 New system: Reply to Peanut4
Diff · Түүх 193 New system: Reply to Peanut4
Diff · Түүх 160 Adding "is a list" to Quick-fail criteria: Okay in principle
Diff · Түүх -79 Adding "is a list" to Quick-fail criteria: Shorter reply
Diff · Түүх 582 Sphinx Head was removed from the nomination in an out-of-process manner.: All GAN actions need a permanently linkable review, however brief
Diff · Түүх 396 Adding "is a list" to Quick-fail criteria: Unnecessary
Diff · Түүх 18 Review page headers: Indent
Diff · Түүх 348 Review page headers: Reply to EyeSerene
Diff · Түүх 1,235 Review page headers: Reply to EyeSerene
Diff · Түүх 1,416 New system: Reply to VT
Diff · Түүх 201 new GA review programme.: Comment
Diff · Түүх 119 Template maintenance...: Asked
Diff · Түүх 36 new GA review programme.: Add that Gwinva is the main user applying the first technique
Diff · Түүх 956 new GA review programme.: Reply ec, and post ec
Diff · Түүх 1,052 Template maintenance...: Replies
Diff · Түүх 1,029 Request: don't make up subpage names: Comment on plans to improve the quality of individual reassessment reviews
Diff · Түүх 437 Request: don't make up subpage names: Reply to Malleus
Diff · Түүх 15 Request: don't make up subpage names: Tweak for clarity
Diff · Түүх 1,427 Request: don't make up subpage names: new section
Diff · Түүх 0 Transition to review subpages: Fix redlink
Diff · Түүх 0 Transition to review subpages: Typo
Diff · Түүх 294 Transition to review subpages: Not a fan but don't object as long as it is not required
Diff · Түүх 350 Subpage problem: Sort of fixed
Diff · Түүх 122 Transition to review subpages: Definite improvement, thanks Dr.C
Diff · Түүх 1,502 Transition to review subpages: Three comments
Diff · Түүх 471 Transition to review subpages: Comments on finishing reviews
Diff · Түүх 1,682 Transition to review subpages: new section
Diff · Түүх 217 Are these relevant instructions or just the first draft (section break): Will comment in a new section
Diff · Түүх 385 Subpage implementation (section break): Reply to Ruslik
Diff · Түүх 485 Subpage implementation (section break): Comment
Diff · Түүх 564 Subpage implementation (section break): Outstanding issues and my movements
Diff · Түүх 286 Subpage implementation (section break): Transitional issues
Diff · Түүх 236 GA reviews in multiple section headers on talk pages: Split off subsection and comment on documentation
Diff · Түүх 0 Have i missed something lol: Typo
Diff · Түүх 2,369 GA reviews in multiple section headers on talk pages: Templates created; describe process
Diff · Түүх 1,334 GA reviews in multiple section headers on talk pages: Demonstrate proposed format (or at least a first draft) to see if there is consensus for it
Diff · Түүх 417 Have i missed something lol: Nice one
Diff · Түүх 646 GA reviews in multiple section headers on talk pages: Need to move in stages
Diff · Түүх 2,183 GA reviews in multiple section headers on talk pages: Details
Diff · Түүх 209 Alternative: Belated comment
Diff · Түүх 169 Alternative: All very well if there is someone who can do it
Diff · Түүх 1,119 Automation redux: Categories created to track errors, and comments
Diff · Түүх 2,960 Automation redux
Diff · Түүх 94 Help at GAR requested: Add a PS.
Diff · Түүх 1,284 Help at GAR requested: new section
Diff · Түүх 47 Long overdue start of new archive
Diff · Түүх 23 White Mountain art was GAR, failed, restored, and has multiple problems: Clarify
Diff · Түүх 552 White Mountain art was GAR, failed, restored, and has multiple problems: Comment
Diff · Түүх 669 White Mountain art was GAR, failed, restored, and has multiple problems: Link to delisting guidelines, and make suggestion
Diff · Түүх 1,144 Naming convention for a figure briefly in spotlight: Reply to Moni
Diff · Түүх 286 Suggestion:
Diff · Түүх 183 User:Dihydrogen Monoxide/GAN passed spam: Yes, it is a good idea to formalize this
Diff · Түүх 546 Permanent GA reviews: Comment
Diff · Түүх 140 Permanent GA reviews: Read the thread
Diff · Түүх 861 Permanent GA reviews: Accountability
Diff · Түүх 311 Permanent GA reviews: Clarify proposal
Diff · Түүх 2 Permanent GA reviews: Fix typo
Diff · Түүх 1,336 Odd method of reviewing: Talk page reviews are not permanent either
Diff · Түүх 727 Simultaneously GA and A-class?: Amplify post ec: each WikiProject reaches its own assessment, not always the same
Diff · Түүх 5 Simultaneously GA and A-class?: Fix my temporary dyslexia
Diff · Түүх 629 Simultaneously GA and A-class?: Not our job
Diff · Түүх 112 Is this an acceptable GA review:
Diff · Түүх 184 Is this an acceptable GA review: Good luck iMatthew
Diff · Түүх 600 Is this an acceptable GA review: Comment
Diff · Түүх 491 Is this an acceptable GA review: No, and the article needs a lot of work
Diff · Түүх 844 Simultaneously GA and A-class?: Explain
Diff · Түүх 562 Advice to article writers: Agree with Malleus and DHMO
Diff · Түүх 770 Gavin Newsom and current political figures in general: Comment and suggestions
Diff · Түүх 334 Can an article be on PR and GAN simultaneously?: It's allowed
Diff · Түүх 343 Auto-fail hold > 7 days: Suggestions
Diff · Түүх 638 Can I review this?: Comments
Diff · Түүх 681 "If you're a registered user ...": Consensus?
Diff · Түүх 248 Auto-fail hold > 7 days: Judgement is for humans to do, not bots :
Diff · Түүх 264 "If you're a registered user ...": In favour of IP noms
Diff · Түүх 1,481 Combined GAN template: Ready for testing on the road
Diff · Түүх 773 If no central training program, then Task Mentors?: Agree, page set up, but article history is for bots, not humans
Diff · Түүх 658 section break: Suggest {{GAN}}
Diff · Түүх 276 section break: StatisticianBot issue
Diff · Түүх 250 More space saving: Good idea
Diff · Түүх 546 Dropping "On hold" and "Second opinion": September 2007 and the rest of WP
Diff · Түүх 339 Dropping "On hold" and "Second opinion": Lightweight
Diff · Түүх 648 Redrafting instructions block: Explain
Diff · Түүх 348 Dropping "On hold" and "Second opinion": Backlog elimination may be a good idea, but it didn't appear to work last time
Diff · Түүх 194 Redrafting instructions block: I don't understand what is easy about making three edits instead of one
Diff · Түүх 562 Dropping "On hold" and "Second opinion": Link, graph and comment
Diff · Түүх 1,060 Redrafting instructions block: I've tried!
Diff · Түүх 544 Dropping "On hold" and "Second opinion": Comfort for the regulars does not attract new reviewers, and they are what GAN needs
Diff · Түүх 157 WP:GAN#Natural_sciences — subheadings: Another option is "engineering"
Diff · Түүх 479 WP:GAN#Natural_sciences — subheadings: Suggest Geography as an alternative
Diff · Түүх 1,315 Dropping "On hold" and "Second opinion": I agree, even though I favour putting articles on hold, and having second reviewers
Diff · Түүх 481 Inviting active projects to help with backlog: Agree and clarify
Diff · Түүх 192 The universe has exploded!: Rumours of the backlog being eliminated have been greatly exaggerated ;
Diff · Түүх 341 Inviting active projects to help with backlog: I agree: add a couple of links
Diff · Түүх 1,757 New proposal of guide for nominators: Comments
Diff · Түүх 791 WP:GAN header: Er, people don't read instructions
Diff · Түүх 627 GAN Reviewer of the Week - w/e 9/2/2008: Eh, where's the banter? Add some :
Diff · Түүх 143 LONG: Done
Diff · Түүх 652 LONG: Over 32KB, but what is the point?
Diff · Түүх 368 Ca existe. Misunderstandings of the GA concept: Explain point of review
Diff · Түүх 531 GA On Hold: Be flexible, I say
Diff · Түүх 51 Ca existe. Misunderstandings of the GA concept: Improve sentence about delisting and clarify timescale
Diff · Түүх 1,542 Proposal: Ca existe. Misunderstandings of the GA concept
Diff · Түүх 353 GAR reviewers needed: Once every week or two would be enough
Diff · Түүх 1,563 GAR reviewers needed: new section
Diff · Түүх 540 Article History Template: GAR/ templates. Do same at GAN?
Diff · Түүх 266 Article History Template: Clarified: please use five tildes in the templates
Diff · Түүх 390 Plan of action: My understanding of the idea
Diff · Түүх 187 No TOC on this page?: __NOTOC__ on this page, to be precise: fixed
Diff · Түүх 0 Revision/simplification of templates, etc.: Remove transclusion of guidelines containing a __NOTOC__
Diff · Түүх 809 Suggestion for backlog: Another backlog elimination drive would help, but is not a long term solution
Diff · Түүх 16 Query re holds and GA requests: clarify: formalities of renomination
Diff · Түүх 258 Query re holds and GA requests: Formalities preferable, but you can pass it quite quickly if it meets the standard
Diff · Түүх 184 Article History Template: Please clarify
Diff · Түүх 246 Article History Template: Not yet
Diff · Түүх 102 Article failed by a major contributor: Thanks VT
Diff · Түүх 144 Article failed by a major contributor: renominate, but GAR is waiting ready if you need it
Diff · Түүх 682 Article History Template: Leave it to the bots
Diff · Түүх 412 Revision/simplification of templates, etc.: Reply to Pete
Diff · Түүх 284 Can nominators review?: No, it seems
Diff · Түүх 1,588 Can nominators review?: Comment
Diff · Түүх 209 Revision/simplification of templates, etc.: You could use GAList/check
Diff · Түүх 341 Can nominators review?: Re Epbr's suggestion
Diff · Түүх 0 Can nominators review?: Fix typo
Diff · Түүх 1,577 Can nominators review?: new section
Diff · Түүх 183 Revision/simplification of templates, etc.: Fix my incorrect comment
Diff · Түүх 418 Image licensing issue: On image page suffices
Diff · Түүх 727 Revision/simplification of templates, etc.: Looks good so far
Diff · Түүх 452 Why is there a backlog and/or lack of reviewers?: Great idea!
Diff · Түүх 199 Quality vs quantity: Agree 100%
Diff · Түүх 388 Quality vs quantity: Which template + addition to guidelines
Diff · Түүх 115 Why is there a backlog and/or lack of reviewers?: Another option for Pete
Diff · Түүх 877 Why is there a backlog and/or lack of reviewers?: Reply to Pete: Use GAList, etc., but leave pass/fail blank until you make your decision
Diff · Түүх 157 Quick Failing an Aricticle due to nominator inactivity: Sure, but it is not a quick fail
Diff · Түүх 426 Wikilinking dates: Not a GA criterion
Diff · Түүх 523 Quality vs quantity: What is undemocratic? I'm curious
Diff · Түүх 13 Theatre, film and drama: Correct name of FA cat
Diff · Түүх -1 Why is there a backlog and/or lack of reviewers?: Bad typo day :
Diff · Түүх -1 Quality vs quantity: Fix (very un-Freudian) typo! :
Diff · Түүх 862 Quality vs quantity: Ask Peanut4?
Diff · Түүх 257 Why is there a backlog and/or lack of reviewers?: Graph
Diff · Түүх 207 Backlog and automation: "A bot failed my article!" - probably not a good idea :
Diff · Түүх 19 Quality vs quantity: Link editor
Diff · Түүх 2,503 Why is there a backlog and/or lack of reviewers?: Two schools
Diff · Түүх 636 Theatre, film and drama: Comment on architecture
Diff · Түүх 1,480 Why is there a backlog and/or lack of reviewers?: Reply to VT
Diff · Түүх 56 Backlog and automation: It seems to me that we need a section break here: feel free to retitle it
Diff · Түүх 264 Theatre, film and drama: Comment on subdividing
Diff · Түүх 1,621 Backlog and automation: Reply to CP
Diff · Түүх -2 Backlog and automation: this->it
Diff · Түүх 620 Backlog and automation: Reply to Ruhrfisch
Diff · Түүх 447 Theatre, film and drama: new section
Diff · Түүх 1,255 Backlog and automation: Reply to DHMO
Diff · Түүх 3,299 Backlog and automation: new section
Diff · Түүх 116 Just Checking: No, it's updated regularly by a bot
Diff · Түүх 75 Just Checking: Wikilink guidelines: it is not a conflict of interest to fix problems with an article under review
Diff · Түүх 875 Just Checking: It is not a conflict of interest to copyedit during a review
Diff · Түүх 521 A-Class nominations: Reply
Diff · Түүх 190 GAN Reviewer of the Week - w/e 15/12/2007: Wishful thinking?
Diff · Түүх 94 Templates: Thanks Pete
Diff · Түүх 576 On hold and second opinion: We lost another potential reviewer
Diff · Түүх 345 Templates: Its just technobabble for different ways of using templates
Diff · Түүх 333 Templates: Subst
Diff · Түүх 260 On hold and second opinion: Insight and wisdom
Diff · Түүх 859 On hold and second opinion: Comments
Diff · Түүх 382 Question about fail: Is it a reliable source?
Diff · Түүх 575 On hold and second opinion: Reply to VT and comment on redlinks
Diff · Түүх 2,584 On hold and second opinion: new section
Diff · Түүх 709 an idea that truly blows goat chunks.. {{tl|GAReview}} templates!: Right idea, wrong template?
Diff · Түүх 178 If you review an article, put it on hold and fix some of the issues yourself, can you pass the article?: Done
Diff · Түүх -631 If you review an article...: Remove duplicate comment apparently in wrong section: Twigboy, revert me if this was your intention
Diff · Түүх 384 If you review an article, put it on hold and fix some of the issues yourself, can you pass the article?: Agree/reply
Diff · Түүх 1,765 If you review an article, put it on hold and fix some of the issues yourself, can you pass the article?: Both tenses are used
Diff · Түүх 488 an idea that truly blows goat chunks.. {{tl|GAReview}} templates!: Multiple reviewers in series
Diff · Түүх 676 an idea that truly blows goat chunks.. {{tl|GAReview}} templates!: Agree with goal, but not approach + note of realism (over ec)
Diff · Түүх 510 an idea that truly blows goat chunks.. {{tl|GAReview}} templates!: WP:OWN is about mainspace, but otherwise, Ling has a point
Diff · Түүх 138 Alphabet: More topical joke? :
Diff · Түүх 399 Alphabet: Order of top-level is used in multiple places
Diff · Түүх 479 Alphabet: This glitch was caused by a recent split
Diff · Түүх 490 Subsubtopics: Issues raised about e.g. "Music"
Diff · Түүх 859 Green: Various replies
Diff · Түүх 699 Tefillin, 17 days on hold: Removed "OnHold"
Diff · Түүх 342 Green: Lighter background adopted, plus attempt to fix first panel
Diff · Түүх 343 Subsubtopics: Done
Diff · Түүх 142 Subsubtopics: Will do
Diff · Түүх 466 Green: Explain cyan: also I tried a lighter colour at WP:WGA
Diff · Түүх 607 Pro Wrestling WikiProject: Not a conflict of interest, but thanks for commenting here
Diff · Түүх 509 Green: The delicate balance between lime and cyan :
Diff · Түүх 396 Green: Try to clarify question in order to understand answers
Diff · Түүх 905 Green: Questions
Diff · Түүх 187 GAList3 is now available: Sorted
Diff · Түүх 401 I will try: Biographies are not listed separately, but within each subject (apologies that no one replied to you sooner)
Diff · Түүх 356 Subsubtopics: new section
Diff · Түүх 301 GAList3 is now available: Deleted: good luck with Balzac!
Diff · Түүх 451 GAList3 is now available: FGAN and PGAN? I can help if you like
Diff · Түүх 307 GAList3 is now available: Clarify, I hope ;
Diff · Түүх 212 Slipping: Nice idea
Diff · Түүх 386 GAList3 is now available: Great, but why the new template name?
Diff · Түүх 462 Slipping: That is what I meant, thanks EyeSerene :
Diff · Түүх 829 Slipping: We need some simplification and automation in my opinion
Diff · Түүх 972 GA review for To Kill a Mockingbird: Reply to Moni3
Diff · Түүх 585 GA review for To Kill a Mockingbird: Remove image
Diff · Түүх 535 GAN Reviewer of the Week - w/e 27/10/2007: Criteria are fairly simple ;
Diff · Түүх 153 Homeopathy nomination: Yu
Diff · Түүх 387 Homeopathy nomination: Check out the talk page maybe?
Diff · Түүх 94 Homeopathy nomination: Which topic?
Diff · Түүх 288 More trouble than it's worth?: If nominators wrongly categorize, recategorize!
Diff · Түүх 83 More trouble than it's worth?: Agree
Diff · Түүх 239 GAN Reviewer of the Week - w/e 13/10/2007: Procedural error? ;
Diff · Түүх 259 Scalability: Discuss automation further at WP:WGA?
Diff · Түүх 664 Scalability: Automation and quality checking
Diff · Түүх 469 Backlog: Wishful thinking
Diff · Түүх 1 Update name
Diff · Түүх 449 Scalability: Two replies
Diff · Түүх 116 Chicago Marathon: Not a serious concern
Diff · Түүх 146 Chicago Marathon: Looks like it fails criterion 5 to me ;
Diff · Түүх 3,250 Scalability: Replies and further thoughts
Diff · Түүх 1 Scalability: tense
Diff · Түүх 52 Scalability: Clarify a few statistical points
Diff · Түүх 2,963 Simplifying GAN: do we need to keep articles under review on this page?: Making this process scalable
Diff · Түүх 1,404 Simplifying GAN: do we need to keep articles under review on this page?: A few replies
Diff · Түүх 359 LONG: It's radical stuff indeed
Diff · Түүх 366 Review workshop: Argued against this, but good luck
Diff · Түүх -139 Update archive
Diff · Түүх 264 LONG: It is just one click awaty
Diff · Түүх 558 Simplifying GAN: do we need to keep articles under review on this page?: It aint about tidying, it is about efficiency
Diff · Түүх 202 Simplifying GAN: do we need to keep articles under review on this page?:
Diff · Түүх 245 LONG: new section
Diff · Түүх 696 Simplifying GAN: do we need to keep articles under review on this page?: Replies and clarifications
Diff · Түүх 1,998 Simplifying GAN: do we need to keep articles under review on this page?: new section
Diff · Түүх -944 Undid revision 161837928 by Derek.cashman (talk) Return GA talk page query to original location
Diff · Түүх 189 Streamlining: More minor changes
Diff · Түүх 639 Streamlining: new section
Diff · Түүх 18 Option 2: Nominations: Page moved and redirects fixed
Diff · Түүх 6 Update archive links
Diff · Түүх 144 How about using {{Y}} and {{N}} in GA Fails so future reviewers know what to look for?: Nice one
Diff · Түүх 0 How about using {{Y}} and {{N}} in GA Fails so future reviewers know what to look for?: Noun not verb, sorryu
Diff · Түүх 315 How about using {{Y}} and {{N}} in GA Fails so future reviewers know what to look for?: Best practise?
Diff · Түүх 106 How about using {{Y}} and {{N}} in GA Fails so future reviewers know what to look for?:
Diff · Түүх 129 How about using {{Y}} and {{N}} in GA Fails so future reviewers know what to look for?: GAList
Diff · Түүх 347 Option 2: Nominations: Admin needed
Diff · Түүх 455 References in the lead section: Footnotes and citations in the lead are permissible but not required
Diff · Түүх 591 Option 2: Nominations: Definitions and practicalities
Diff · Түүх 545 Option 2: Nominations: GAR and nominee/nomination
Diff · Түүх 3,149 A rose by any other name: new section
Diff · Түүх 309 Wikiproject logic exists, should a Logic category exist also?: I think it is unnecessary and unhelpful
Diff · Түүх 522 {{tl|ArticleHistory}}: Fixed
All times are in UTC.

Leave a Reply