Cannabis Ruderalis

Content deleted Content added
IBeatAnorexia (talk | contribs)
In regards to controversy and improper interpretations, an elaboration is given. Please discuss on talk page before removing large sections of content.
Randy Kryn (talk | contribs)
Undid revision per the previous reverts
Tag: Undo
 
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Short description|Wikipedia policy on Wikipedia not having firm rules}}
{| class="messagebox"
{{Pp-semi|small=yes}}
|-
{{Policy|WP:IAR|WP:IGNORE}}
| [[Image:Green check.png|30px]]
{{Short URL box|i}}
| '''This page is an [[Wikipedia:Policies and guidelines|official policy]] on the English Wikipedia.'''<ref>[http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia%3AIgnore_all_rules&diff=70516723 "IAR is policy, always has been"] (edit summary by [[Jimmy Wales|Jimbo Wales]], August 19, 2006)</ref> The concept expressed below is fundamental to the encyclopedia's operation. It has a long tradition<ref>[http://nostalgia.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rules_to_consider "If rules make you nervous and depressed..."] (original version of this page by [[Larry Sanger]])</ref> and a deep and subtle meaning. Please consider this before editing the page. When in doubt, discuss first on the [[Wikipedia talk:Ignore all rules|talk page]].
|{{shortcut|[[WP:IAR]]}}
|}

[[Wikipedia:Policies and guidelines|The rules]], as they are written, are so done with the intent to guide editors of this vast community in making proper decisions based on reasonable guidance. However, a rule is rarely meant to be absolute. If a you feel better decisions can be made, but they go against the rules or otherwise do not follow their stance, it is better to think of alternatives. These guidlelines are not meant to invoke [[Laziness|slothfulness]], or to otherwise override consensus.

If what you are doing is improving or maintaining Wikipedia, and the rules state otherwise, '''ignore them'''.

== Controversy ==

Although "Ignore all rules" is a legitimate and essential policy, controversy does exist.
'''Laziness:''' Generally speaking, you are never improving Wikipedia in the aspect of being lazy. Always follow up your edits with a summary and explaination (if such is appropriate).

'''Consensus:''' Consensus is a major element of Wikipedia that cannot be ignored for long before a long discussion ensues. If you feel it is absolutely necessary to act against consensus, then be prepared to be reverted, and to explain yourself in detail, repeatedly. Remember that revert warring against consensus doesn't work, and in the end, if you can't convince people that your action was correct, be prepared to accept that you've been overruled by the community.

'''Being a dick:''' (see [[meta:Don't be a dick]]) Let us put it this way: don't be a dick. You may invoke ''Ignore all rules'' all you want, but that doesn't make it courteous or acceptable to ignore good faith request for explanation. "I did it because of IAR" is not a complete answer; if you ignore a rule, and are challenged, then civility requires that you explain yourself.

== Varying Viewpoints ==

Some people look at ''ignore all rules'' as the central policy; as the ''rule of all rules''. Others however, may feel that ignore all rules is subjective, or that it only applies to small criteria and simple dilemas such as deleting a CSD that doesn't meet any criteria, but is obviously not improving Wikipedia in any shape or form.

'''What is the proper interpretation of this guideline?:''' Ignore all rules is exactly what is stated: "If the rules prevent you from ''improving'' or ''maintaining'' Wikipedia, '''ignore them'''. The problem that many people run into is consensus. If a majority of people agreed that something was good. The edit or change made was determined to be improvement, but the rules applied a level of controversy, then this majority is free to make the edit without worrying about these rules.
== Statements by the Arbitration Committee ==

The [[WP:ARBCOM|Arbitration Committee]] has made the following statements regarding Ignore All Rules:
* [[Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/Daniel_Brandt_deletion_wheel_war#Ignoring_all_rules|Daniel Brandt deletion wheel war]]
<blockquote>
Wikipedia has many policies and processes that affect deletion and undeletion of pages. Where there is strong community support (or minimally, a lack of objections), it is sometimes permissible to sidestep or otherwise take liberties with these process. Those who ignore all rules should proceed slowly and deliberately; act only when informed by any existing discussion, history, or logs; and should be prepared to explain the reasoning for their actions. If ensuing discussion shows an absence of community support, practitioners of Ignore All Rules should have the grace to revert their own actions.
</blockquote>


<onlyinclude>If a [[Wikipedia:Policies and guidelines|rule]] prevents you from improving or maintaining [[Wikipedia]], {{Strong|ignore it}}.</onlyinclude>


== See also ==
== See also ==
{{Spoken Wikipedia|Ignore_all_rules.ogg|2006-05-16}}
{{Spoken Wikipedia|Wikipedia Ignore All Rules.ogg|date=25 September 2011}}
* [[meta:Don't be a dick]]
* [[Wikipedia:Be bold|Be bold]]
* [[Wikipedia:Five pillars#WP:5P5| Wikipedia's fifth pillar: Wikipedia has no firm rules]]
* [[Wikipedia:Use common sense]]
* List of [[Wikipedia:"Ignore all rules" essays and related topics|"Ignore all rules" essays and related topics]]
* [[Wikipedia:Consensus]]
* [[Ignore all rules]]
* [[Wikipedia:Be bold in updating pages|Wikipedia:Be bold]]
* [[Letter and spirit of the law]]
* [[Wikipedia:Trifecta]]

== References ==
{{reflist}}

{{Wikipedia principles}}


{{Wikipedia policies and guidelines|state=collapsed}}
[[Category:Wikipedia official policy|Ignore all rules]]
[[Category:Wikipedia culture|Ignore all rules]]
[[Category:Wikipedia process discussions|Ignore all rules]]


__NOEDITSECTION__
[[ar:ويكيبيديا:تجاهل كل القواعد]]
[[Category:Wikipedia basic information]]
[[br:Lammit dreist ar reolennoù]]
[[Category:Wikipedia policies]]
[[cs:Wikipedie:Nevšímejte si žádných pravidel]]
[[de:Wikipedia:Ignoriere alle Regeln]]
[[es:Wikipedia:Ignora las normas]]
[[fr:Wikipédia:De l'interprétation créative des règles]]
[[it:Wikipedia:Ignora le regole]]
[[hu:Wikipédia:Ne törődj a szabályokkal]]
[[id:Wikipedia:Jangan terbebani aturan]]
[[ja:Wikipedia:ルールすべてを無視しなさい]]
[[ms:Wikipedia:Jangan hirau peraturan]]
[[no:Wikipedia:Ignorer alle regler]]
[[pl:Wikipedia:Ignoruj wszystkie zasady]]
[[ru:Википедия:Игнорируйте все правила]]
[[sr:Википедија:Игнориши сва правила]]
[[sv:Wikipedia:Strunta i reglerna]]
[[uk:Вікіпедія:Ігноруйте усі правила]]
[[zh:Wikipedia:忽略所有规则]]

Latest revision as of 09:46, 6 June 2024

If a rule prevents you from improving or maintaining Wikipedia, ignore it.

See also

Listen to this page (1 minute)
Spoken Wikipedia icon
This audio file was created from a revision of this page dated 25 September 2011 (2011-09-25), and does not reflect subsequent edits.

Leave a Reply