Functional selectivity (or “agonist trafficking”, “biased agonism”, “biased signaling”, "ligand bias" and “differential engagement”) is the ligand-dependent selectivity for certain signal transduction pathways relative to a reference ligand (often the endogenous hormone or peptide) at the same receptor. Functional selectivity can be present when a receptor has several possible signal transduction pathways. To which degree each pathway is activated thus depends on which ligand binds to the receptor. Functional selectivity, or biased signaling, is most extensively characterized at G protein coupled receptors (GPCRs). A number of biased agonists, such as those at muscarinic M2 receptors tested as analgesics or antiproliferative drugs, or those at opioid receptors that mediate pain, show potential at various receptor families to increase beneficial properties while reducing side effects. For example, pre-clinical studies with G protein biased agonists at the mu opioid receptor show equivalent efficacy for treating pain with reduced risk for addictive potential and respiratory depression. Studies within the chemokine receptor system also suggest that GPCR biased agonism is physiologically relevant. For example, a beta-arrestin biased agonist of the chemokine receptor CXCR3 induced greater chemotaxis of T cells relative to a G protein biased agonist.
Functional vs. traditional selectivity
Functional selectivity has been proposed to broaden conventional definitions of pharmacology.
Traditional pharmacology posits that a ligand can be either classified as an agonist (full or partial), antagonist or more recently an inverse agonist through a specific receptor subtype, and that this characteristic will be consistent with all effector (second messenger) systems coupled to that receptor. While this dogma has been the backbone of ligand-receptor interactions for decades now, more recent data indicates that this classic definition of ligand-protein associations does not hold true for a number of compounds; such compounds may be termed as mixed agonist-antagonists.
Functional selectivity posits that a ligand may inherently produce a mix of the classic characteristics through a single receptor isoform depending on the effector pathway coupled to that receptor. For instance, a ligand can not easily be classified as an agonist or antagonist, because it can be a little of both, depending on its preferred signal transduction pathways. Thus, such ligands must instead be classified on the basis of their individual effects in the cell, instead of being either an agonist or antagonist to a receptor.
It is also important to note that these observations were made in a number of different expression systems and therefore functional selectivity is not just an epiphenomenon of one particular expression system.
One notable example of functional selectivity occurs with the 5-HT2A receptor, as well as the 5-HT2C receptor. Serotonin, the main endogenous ligand of 5-HT receptors, is a functionally selective agonist at this receptor, activating phospholipase C (which leads to inositol triphosphate accumulation), but does not activate phospholipase A2, which would result in arachidonic acid signaling. However, the other endogenous compound dimethyltryptamine activates arachidonic acid signaling at the 5-HT2A receptor, as do many exogenous hallucinogens such as DOB and lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD). Notably, LSD does not activate IP3 signaling through this receptor to any significant extent. Oligomers; specifically 5-HT2A–mGluR2 heteromers mediate this effect. This may explain why some direct 5-HT2 receptor agonists have psychedelic effects, whereas compounds that indirectly increase serotonin signaling at the 5-HT2 receptors generally do not, for example: selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs), and medications using 5HT2A receptor agonists that do not have constitutive activity at the mGluR2 dimer, such as lisuride.
Oliceridine is a mu opioid receptor agonist that has been described to be functionally selective towards G protein and away from β-arrestin2 pathways. However, recent reports highlight that, rather than functional selectivity or 'G protein bias', this agonist has low intrinsic efficacy. In vivo, it has been reported to mediate pain relief without tolerance nor gastrointestinal side effects.
The delta opioid receptor agonists SNC80 and ARM390 demonstrate functional selectivity that is thought to be due to their differing capacity to cause receptor internalization. While SNC80 causes delta opioid receptors to internalize, ARM390 causes very little receptor internalization. Functionally, that means that the effects of SNC80 (e.g. analgesia) do not occur when a subsequent dose follows the first, whereas the effects of ARM390 persist. However, tolerance to ARM390's analgesia still occurs eventually after multiple doses, though through a mechanism that does not involve receptor internalization. Interestingly, the other effects of ARM390 (e.g. decreased anxiety) persist after tolerance to its analgesic effects has occurred.
- Smith, Jeffrey S.; Lefkowitz, Robert J.; Rajagopal, Sudarshan (2018-01-05). "Biased signalling: from simple switches to allosteric microprocessors". Nature Reviews. Drug Discovery. 17 (4): 243–260. doi:10.1038/nrd.2017.229. ISSN 1474-1784. PMC 5936084. PMID 29302067.
- Simmons MA (June 2005). "Functional selectivity, ligand-directed trafficking, conformation-specific agonism: what's in a name?". Mol. Interv. 5 (3): 154–7. doi:10.1124/mi.5.3.4. PMID 15994454.
- Bock, Andreas; Merten, Nicole; Schrage, Ramona; Dallanoce, Clelia; Bätz, Julia; Klöckner, Jessica; Schmitz, Jens; Matera, Carlo; Simon, Katharina; Kebig, Anna; Peters, Lucas; Müller, Anke; Schrobang-Ley, Jasmin; Tränkle, Christian; Hoffmann, Carsten; De Amici, Marco; Holzgrabe, Ulrike; Kostenis, Evi; Mohr, Klaus (2012). "The allosteric vestibule of a seven transmembrane helical receptor controls G-protein coupling". Nature Communications. 3 (1): 1044. Bibcode:2012NatCo...3.1044B. doi:10.1038/ncomms2028. ISSN 2041-1723. PMC 3658004. PMID 22948826.
- Matera, Carlo; Flammini, Lisa; Quadri, Marta; Vivo, Valentina; Ballabeni, Vigilio; Holzgrabe, Ulrike; Mohr, Klaus; De Amici, Marco; Barocelli, Elisabetta; Bertoni, Simona; Dallanoce, Clelia (2014). "Bis(ammonio)alkane-type agonists of muscarinic acetylcholine receptors: Synthesis, in vitro functional characterization, and in vivo evaluation of their analgesic activity". European Journal of Medicinal Chemistry. 75: 222–232. doi:10.1016/j.ejmech.2014.01.032. ISSN 0223-5234. PMID 24534538.
- Cristofaro, Ilaria; Spinello, Zaira; Matera, Carlo; Fiore, Mario; Conti, Luciano; De Amici, Marco; Dallanoce, Clelia; Tata, Ada Maria (2018). "Activation of M2 muscarinic acetylcholine receptors by a hybrid agonist enhances cytotoxic effects in GB7 glioblastoma cancer stem cells". Neurochemistry International. 118: 52–60. doi:10.1016/j.neuint.2018.04.010. ISSN 0197-0186. PMID 29702145. S2CID 207125517.
- Manglik, Aashish; Lin, Henry; Aryal, Dipendra K.; McCorvy, John D.; Dengler, Daniela; Corder, Gregory; Levit, Anat; Kling, Ralf C.; Bernat, Viachaslau (8 September 2016). "Structure-based discovery of opioid analgesics with reduced side effects". Nature. 537 (7619): 185–190. Bibcode:2016Natur.537..185M. doi:10.1038/nature19112. ISSN 1476-4687. PMC 5161585. PMID 27533032.
- Smith, Jeffrey S.; Nicholson, Lowell T.; Suwanpradid, Jutamas; Glenn, Rachel A.; Knape, Nicole M.; Alagesan, Priya; Gundry, Jaimee N.; Wehrman, Thomas S.; Atwater, Amber Reck (2018-11-06). "Biased agonists of the chemokine receptor CXCR3 differentially control chemotaxis and inflammation". Science Signaling. 11 (555): eaaq1075. doi:10.1126/scisignal.aaq1075. ISSN 1937-9145. PMC 6329291. PMID 30401786.
- Urban JD, Clarke WP, von Zastrow M, Nichols DE, Kobilka B, Weinstein H, Javitch JA, Roth BL, Christopoulos A, Sexton PM, Miller KJ, Spedding M, Mailman RB (January 2007). "Functional selectivity and classical concepts of quantitative pharmacology". J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther. 320 (1): 1–13. doi:10.1124/jpet.106.104463. PMID 16803859. S2CID 447937.
- Samuels BA, Nautiyal KM, Kruegel AC, Levinstein MR, Magalong VM, Gassaway MM, Grinnell SG, Han J, Ansonoff MA, Pintar JE, Javitch JA, Sames D, Hen R (2017). "The Behavioral Effects of the Antidepressant Tianeptine Require the Mu Opioid Receptor". Neuropsychopharmacology. 42 (10): 2052–2063. doi:10.1038/npp.2017.60. PMC 5561344. PMID 28303899.
- Cavalla, D; Chianelli, F (August 2015). "Tianeptine prevents respiratory depression without affecting analgesic effect of opiates in conscious rats". European Journal of Pharmacology. 761: 268–272. doi:10.1016/j.ejphar.2015.05.067. PMID 26068549.
- DeWire SM, Yamashita DS, Rominger DH, Liu G, Cowan CL, Graczyk TM, Chen XT, Pitis PM, Gotchev D, Yuan C, Koblish M, Lark MW, Violin JD (March 2013). "A G protein-biased ligand at the μ-opioid receptor is potently analgesic with reduced gastrointestinal and respiratory dysfunction compared with morphine". Journal of Pharmacology and Experimental Therapeutics. 344 (3): 708–17. doi:10.1124/jpet.112.201616. PMID 23300227. S2CID 8785003.
- Gillis, A; Gondin, AB; Kliewer, A; Sanchez, J; Lim, HD; Alamein, C; Manandhar, P; Santiago, M; Fritzwanker, S; Schmiedel, F; Katte, TA; Reekie, T; Grimsey, NL; Kassiou, M; Kellam, B; Krasel, C; Halls, ML; Connor, M; Lane, JR; Schulz, S; Christie, MJ; Canals, M (31 March 2020). "Low intrinsic efficacy for G protein activation can explain the improved side effect profiles of new opioid agonists". Science Signaling. 13 (625): eaaz3140. doi:10.1126/scisignal.aaz3140. PMID 32234959. S2CID 214771721.
- Pradhan, Amynah A.; Befort, Katia; Nozaki, Chihiro; Gavériaux-Ruff, Claire; Kieffer, Brigitte L. (October 2011). "The delta opioid receptor: an evolving target for the treatment of brain disorders". Trends in Pharmacological Sciences. 32 (10): 581–590. doi:10.1016/j.tips.2011.06.008. PMC 3197801. PMID 21925742.
- Tan L, Yan W, McCorvy JD, Cheng J (July 2018). "Biased Ligands of G Protein-Coupled Receptors: Structure-Functional Selectivity Relationships (SFSRs) and Therapeutic Potential". J. Med. Chem. 61 (22): 9841–9878. doi:10.1021/acs.jmedchem.8b00435. PMID 29939744.
- Costa-Neto CM, Parreiras-E-Silva LT, Bouvier M (2016). "A Pluridimensional View of Biased Agonism". Mol. Pharmacol. 90 (5): 587–595. doi:10.1124/mol.116.105940. PMID 27638872.
- Gesty-Palmer D, Luttrell LM (2011). "Refining efficacy: exploiting functional selectivity for drug discovery". Pharmacology of G Protein Coupled Receptors. Adv. Pharmacol. Advances in Pharmacology. 62. pp. 79–107. doi:10.1016/B978-0-12-385952-5.00009-9. ISBN 9780123859525. PMID 21907907.
- DeWire SM, Violin JD (July 2011). "Biased ligands for better cardiovascular drugs: dissecting G-protein-coupled receptor pharmacology". Circ. Res. 109 (2): 205–16. doi:10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.110.231308. PMID 21737816.
- Kenakin T (1995). "Agonist-Receptor Efficacy. II. Agonist Trafficking of Receptor Signals". Trends Pharmacol Sci. 16 (7): 232–8. doi:10.1016/S0165-6147(00)89032-X. PMID 7667897.