How this document has been cited
"Indeed, there are many authorities which go to the extent of holding that in criminal cases a forcible abduction is no sufficient reason why the party should not answer when brought within the jurisdiction of the court which has the right to try him for such an offense, and presents no valid objection to his trial in such court.
- in United States v. Insull, 1934 and 9 similar citations
—where the accused was arrested in Brussels by a British police officer and forcibly returned to stand trial in England, and the court held that it could not inquire into the circumstances of the arrest or the accused's return to the English jurisdiction
- in Combatting Torture: Revitalizing the Toscanino Exception to the Ker-Frisbie … and 7 similar citations
—one accused of crime against the laws of England, and who was in custody for trial, sought to be discharged upon habeas corpus because she had been improperly apprehended in a foreign country.
- in Pettibone v. Nichols, 1906 and 6 similar citations
But sometimes, as upon a charge of perjury, a foreign country will allow the removal of an offender even in case of a misdemeanor.
- in The Law of Nations; Or, The Principles of Natural Law and 8 similar citations
A foreign government has no right, by the Law of Nations, to demand of the government of the United States a surrender of a citizen or subject of such foreign government, who has committed a crime in his own country
- in The Law of Nations; Or, The Principles of Natural Law and 6 similar citations
In a recent case where a party against whom a true bill for perjury had been found, and a warrant for her apprehension granted, was apprehended abroad, and brought here in custody and committed to prison for want of bail, the court refused to discharge her on the ground that she had been improperly apprehended in a foreign country
- in The Justice of the Peace and Parish Officer: In Six Volumes and 6 similar citations
—an individual, under indictment in England, had no right to be released by reason of bis illegal arrest by a state agent in Belgium.
- in Kidnaping of Fugitives from Justice on Foreign Territory and 4 similar citations
But decisions relying upon this proposition have not been founded upon an adequate consideration of the effect to be attributed to an arrest abroad in violation of treaty or international law.
- in Legal Essays: In Tribute to Orrin Kip McMurray and 5 similar citations
At common law, the fact that kidnapping secured a criminal defendant's physical presence was no bar to jurisdiction
- in Accuracy and adjudication: the promise of extraterritorial due process and 4 similar citations
Interestingly, initial practice of male captus bene detentus was largely predicated upon an early British case
- in Kidnapping Terrorists: Extraterritorial Forcible Abductions in the Global … and 4 similar citations
Cited by
106 Ohio App. 481 - Ohio: Court of Appeals 1958
203 US 192 - Supreme Court 1906
167 US 120 - Supreme Court 1897
127 US 700 - Supreme Court 1888
119 US 436 - Supreme Court 1886
PL Murphy - 2014
H BECKENHAM -
E parte Pinochet -
J Quigley - World Justice?, 2021