Chicago Smooth (talk | contribs) Chicago Smooth added his perspective on the "editing controversy" created by user davidwiz |
Chicago Smooth (talk | contribs) m Added my signature with the four ~~~~ |
||
| Line 27: | Line 27: | ||
The page for Alan Roger Currie has been maintained without interruption for almost a year, if not longer. Many editors have viewed this page, and found that it was fine. I spoke directly with at least two editors, to seek approval, and none of them had a problem with it. Now, all of the sudden, {{user|davidwiz}} comes along, and starts making all sorts of changes, deletions, and modifications. I think this is something personal. |
The page for Alan Roger Currie has been maintained without interruption for almost a year, if not longer. Many editors have viewed this page, and found that it was fine. I spoke directly with at least two editors, to seek approval, and none of them had a problem with it. Now, all of the sudden, {{user|davidwiz}} comes along, and starts making all sorts of changes, deletions, and modifications. I think this is something personal. |
||
I do not work directly for modeone.net, but I am a friend of Book Author Alan Roger Currie. He is a well-respected author, and deserves to have his bio and story told. This is some sort of blatant, personal attack on Mr. Currie by {{user|davidwiz}} |
I do not work directly for modeone.net, but I am a friend of Book Author Alan Roger Currie. He is a well-respected author, and deserves to have his bio and story told. This is some sort of blatant, personal attack on Mr. Currie by {{user|davidwiz}}[[User:Chicago Smooth|Chicago Smooth]] ([[User talk:Chicago Smooth|talk]]) 23:31, 30 September 2008 (UTC) |
||
==== What would you like to change about that? ==== |
==== What would you like to change about that? ==== |
||
Revision as of 23:31, 30 September 2008
| Wikipedia Mediation Cabal | |
|---|---|
 | |
| Status | new |
| Request date | 20:57, 30 September 2008 (UTC) |
| Requesting party | Unknown |
[[Category:Wikipedia Medcab new cases|]][[Category:Wikipedia medcab maintenance|]]
- Note: Please limit posts to this page to brief statements about the nature of the dispute until a volunteer adopts the case. Keep ongoing discussions about the topic to the appropriate talk page(s), but feel free to provide links to the talk page(s) where discussion has happened (and may be ongoing) for the convenience of the informal mediator and other parties. This will help keep discussion from fragmenting out across more pages and make it easier for a volunteer to review the case. Thanks!
Request details
Who are the involved parties?
Chicago Smooth (talk · contribs) davidwiz (talk · contribs)
What's going on?
The original creator of this article Chicago Smooth (talk · contribs) wrote a page that was filled with blatant press release verbage. Anytime anyone attempts to remove the language that violates NPOV Chicago Smooth (talk · contribs) reverts it without any explanation. Lastly, Chicago Smooth (talk · contribs) removed the POV tag and [citation needed] tags on unsourced statements without any explanation.
It is clear that Chicago Smooth (talk · contribs) *is* Alan Roger Currie - look on the Talk page for Chicago Smooth (talk · contribs) and you will see that Chicago Smooth (talk · contribs) works for modeone.net, which is Currie's company.
The page for Alan Roger Currie has been maintained without interruption for almost a year, if not longer. Many editors have viewed this page, and found that it was fine. I spoke directly with at least two editors, to seek approval, and none of them had a problem with it. Now, all of the sudden, davidwiz (talk · contribs) comes along, and starts making all sorts of changes, deletions, and modifications. I think this is something personal.
I do not work directly for modeone.net, but I am a friend of Book Author Alan Roger Currie. He is a well-respected author, and deserves to have his bio and story told. This is some sort of blatant, personal attack on Mr. Currie by davidwiz (talk · contribs)Chicago Smooth (talk) 23:31, 30 September 2008 (UTC)
What would you like to change about that?
Either delete the page b/c it was created by Alan Roger Currie or ensure that this page is free from press release verbage and adheres to NPOV.
The page for Alan Roger Currie should have never been massively edited like it was by davidwiz (talk · contribs). This page was created in late July of 2007, and at least four or more editors viewed the page for Alan Roger Currie between August 2007 and December 2007, and none had any major problems with it. I believe this is some sort of "personal attack" on the author by davidwiz (talk · contribs). I recommend that the only thing that be deleted and/or edited out are those comments or pieces of information that blatantly violate a policy held by Wikipedia.org Chicago Smooth (talk) 23:19, 30 September 2008 (UTC)