Cannabis Indica

How this document has been cited

—absent a saving clause, a criminal defendant is entitled to the benefit of a change in the law during the pendency of his appeal
- in People v. Garza, 2011 and 45 similar citations
"[A] bsent a saving clause, a defendant is entitled to the benefit of a more recent statute which mitigates the punishment for the offense or decriminalizes the conduct altogether.[Citations
- in People v. Harris, 2010 and 27 similar citations
It held that `... the common law principles reiterated in Estrada apply a fortiori when criminal sanctions have been completely repealed before a criminal conviction becomes final
- in People v. Wright, 2006 and 12 similar citations
Where the amending statute mitigates punishment and there is no saving clause the rule is that the amended statute will apply retroactively
- in People v. Robinson, 2010 and 11 similar citations
—the Legislature amended the statute under which the defendants were charged during the pendency of their appeals.(Ibid.)
- in People v. Bruce, 2010 and 7 similar citations
As Bates points out, the Estrada exception has been applied in numerous contexts where the punishment for a particular crime has been lightened, the elements of proof required to convict a defendant of a particular crime have been broadened, or the defenses available to a defendant for a particular crime have been expanded
- in People v. Bates, 2015 and 4 similar citations
Certainly, the mere fact that a court has already addressed an issue in a case poses no insuperable constitutional bar to legislative activity affecting resolution of that issue
- in People v. Esquivel, 2021 and 4 similar citations

Cited by

Cal: Court of Appeal, 6th Appellate Dist. 2010
Cal: Court of Appeal, 6th Appellate Dist. 2010
Cal: Court of Appeal, 6th Appellate Dist. 2010
10 Cal. App. 5th 327 - Cal: Court of Appeal, 6th Appellate Dist. 2017
Cal: Court of Appeal, 4th Appellate Dist., 1st Div. 2015
Cal: Court of Appeal, 6th Appellate Dist. 2011
228 Cal. App. 3d 662 - Cal: Court of Appeal, 6th Appellate Dist. 1991
88 Cal. App. 5th 358 - Cal: Court of Appeal, 4th Appellate Dist., 1st Div. 2023
77 Cal. App. 5th 469 - Cal: Court of Appeal, 2nd Appellate Dist., 1st Div. 2022
Cal: Court of Appeal, 5th Appellate Dist. 2022

Leave a Reply