Content deleted Content added
explaining why the phoney baloney rationalization doesn't meet legal requirements |
Butseriouslyfolks (talk | contribs) let's discuss it first, please? |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
'''The issue whether this image can be used consistent with [[WP:FU]] is being discussed at [[WP:FUR#13_July_2007]]. Please allow that discussion to run its course.''' |
|||
{{del|This images has been deleted probably some 20 times now under various names.... no fair use, not cover art that was used as cover, needs a speedy delete as recreation of deleted image, and the guy who keeps uploading it needs to get blocked so he knows not to pull this crap.... I mean, seriously, how many times do we have to delete this thing, he's just stubbornly refusing to listen}} |
|||
==Summary== |
==Summary== |
||
{{Non-free media rationale |
{{Non-free media rationale |
||
| Description = Typhoid Mary, in art from the original cover to ''Daredevil'' #46 (modifed by Marvel to remove the exposed nipple before releasing), by Alex Maleev. '''There is no fair use rationale for using artwork that never actually ran on a cover.''' |
| Description = Typhoid Mary, in art from the original cover to ''Daredevil'' #46 (modifed by Marvel to remove the exposed nipple before releasing), by Alex Maleev. '''There is no fair use rationale for using artwork that never actually ran on a cover.''' Does not have to be a cover to be fair use. It is a depiction of a character. |
||
| Source = [http://newsarama.com/forums/showthread.php?s=c04cffcc9aed593204a4a46694054c14&threadid=4185] '''This is not an official Marvel source, it's a copyright violation. It's just some forum using the copyrighted image without permission.''' |
| Source = [http://newsarama.com/forums/showthread.php?s=c04cffcc9aed593204a4a46694054c14&threadid=4185] '''This is not an official Marvel source, it's a copyright violation. It's just some forum using the copyrighted image without permission.''' |
||
| Portion = complete image |
|||
| Portion = image released by publisher for promotional purposes. '''There is no proof of this, this is wishful thinking on the part of the person who uploaded the image... and beyond wishful thinking as it has been deleted multiple times as a copyright violation''' |
|||
| Resolution =yes |
| Resolution = yes |
||
| Purpose = [[Typhoid Mary (comics)]]: For identification purposes in conjunction with discussion of the topics. |
| Purpose = [[Typhoid Mary (comics)]]: For identification purposes in conjunction with discussion of the topics. |
||
| Replaceability = No free use image available. '''Actual image of real cover has been uploaded in the past... that could maybe fit fair use rationale as the actual cover art, but the editor who uploaded this one refused to allow the better one to be used, thus invalidating replaceability arguments''' |
| Replaceability = No free use image available. '''Actual image of real cover has been uploaded in the past... that could maybe fit fair use rationale as the actual cover art, but the editor who uploaded this one refused to allow the better one to be used, thus invalidating replaceability arguments''' The real cover image is still not a free replacement. |
||
| other_information = {{Template:Marvel-Comics-trademark-copyright|2007}} |
| other_information = {{Template:Marvel-Comics-trademark-copyright|2007}} |
||
}} |
}} |
||
Revision as of 07:28, 14 July 2007
The issue whether this image can be used consistent with WP:FU is being discussed at WP:FUR#13_July_2007. Please allow that discussion to run its course.
Summary
| Article |
[[{{{Article}}}]] |
|---|---|
| Purpose of use |
Typhoid Mary (comics): For identification purposes in conjunction with discussion of the topics. |
| Replaceable? |
No free use image available. Actual image of real cover has been uploaded in the past... that could maybe fit fair use rationale as the actual cover art, but the editor who uploaded this one refused to allow the better one to be used, thus invalidating replaceability arguments The real cover image is still not a free replacement. |
File history
Click on a date/time to view the file as it appeared at that time.
| Date/Time | Thumbnail | Dimensions | User | Comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| current | 23:49, 19 April 2012 |  | 262 × 400 (35 KB) | DASHBot (talk | contribs) | Bot: Rescaling Fair Use Image (shutoff) |
You cannot overwrite this file.
File usage
The following pages on the English Wikipedia use this file (pages on other projects are not listed):
