The following content has been republished from the Wikimedia Blog. Any views expressed in this piece are not necessarily shared by the Signpost; responses and critical commentary are invited in the comments. For more information on this partnership, see our content guidelines.
Discuss this story
I had a brief glance thru the images in the "Mittelholzer-Abyssinia flight 1934" group, which by their name ought to be images mostly about Ethiopia. Since I've had a hand in writing the majority of the articles about that country, I'm probably as qualified as anyone to categorize them. What I found was while many of these could be valuable contributions, almost all need much more background information to be truly useful. For example, one of the first I looked at was labelled "ETH-BIB-Abessinier an einfachem Grab-Abessinienflug 1934-LBS MH02-22-0281.tif", which, as the title says, is a photo of a simple grave in Africa; however, there is nothing about the grave -- which is a simple wooden cross -- or the man sitting next to it with his head covered -- is he crying? Was the person buried there a relative? Or is he simply resting in the shade of the trees & has nothing to do with the grave? And then there is "ETH-BIB-Alte abessinische Wandmalereien in Kirche-Abessinienflug 1934-LBS MH02-22-0299.tif" -- a photo of a wall painting inside of an Ethiopian church. The style is clearly Amharic, & since it was taken before the Second Italo-Abyssinian War, this may be an image of a lost work of art that has been destroyed in the 80 years since. Yet all we know is what the title of the photo tells us. A third -- & stupidly frustrating -- example are several photos described as "Die zwei Töchter des Kaisers im Palastpark" ("Two daughters of the Emperor in the Palace Gardens"): which two daughters of the Emperor are these? Haile Selassie had four.
Interspersed with these "Abyssinian" photos are photos of adjacent countries: several of Petra in modern Jordan, some of Jerusalem, & some of Sudan. As a result, photos tagged simply "Markt im Abissinien" could actually have been taken anywhere. As I said, there are some potentially invaluable images here, but it will take a very long time to provide more than some simple & possibly unhelpful category tags for them. (I added one, which I suspect is wrong.) -- llywrch (talk) 22:03, 7 September 2016 (UTC)[reply]