- Given that much of the evidence provided to date involves the various blocks imposed on Malleus Fatuorum, I think there is benefit to everyone to review these blocks specifically. With Courcelles' assistance, we have created a chart with all of Malleus Fatuorum's blocks, and filled in date and time, blocking admin, unblock information if applicable, original length of block, and actual length of block. I am hoping that the participants in this case will work collaboratively to provide the following information for *each* block in Malleus' block log:
- Issue that led to block. Include all relevant links, including any discussions on user talk pages.
- Any other dispute resolution attempted before block (warnings, discussion with user, discussion on noticeboards or elsewhere, etc). Links to these attempts.
- Whether or not any other users were also asked to change behaviour/warned/blocked in relation to the same issue. Links to those dispute resolution steps.
- Length of time between last discussion of precipitating issue and the block. (For example, was the last related comment several hours before the block?)
| Date and time of block | Blocking admin | Issue that led to block (link to discussion) | Dispute resolution attempts before block (link to discussion) | Other users advised, warned or blocked (link to discussion) | Time between end of discussion and block | Unblock (with unblock reason) if applicable | Intended duration of block | Actual duration of block |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Example: Link to discussion on Wikipedia talk:Requests for adminship. | Example: Link to discussion on Malleus' talk page. Link to discussion on another page. | Example: Link to discussion on another user's talk page. | Example: Calculate time (days/hours/minutes) between end of discussion and block. | (Users may add links to relevant unblock discussions) | ||||
| 17:26, 24 May 2008 | Swatjester (talk · contribs) | Context [1][2][3]; Warned for [4]; Blocked for [5]. | Full discussion including formal warning, block notice (1 min after block) for comments directed at Swat. Another "warning" [6] | ST47 warned [7] for personal attacks, not blocked. | 4 hrs 27 min | 00:29, 25 May 2008 Balloonman unblocked (block inappropriately applied) | 24 hours | 7 hr 3 min |
| 10:23, 19 August 2008 | Ckatz (talk · contribs) | Context [8]; Wikiquette opened for [9]; Blocked for [10][11][12] [13][14][15][16] | Warning and discussion [17]; Block notice [18] (1 min after block) | 14 mins | 18:33, 19 August 2008 Gwen Gale unblocked ("time served" - asking this editor to be more civil though) | 24 hours | 8 hr 10 min | |
| 00:28, 7 March 2009 | Aitias (talk · contribs) | Context [19]; Blocked for [20] | Discussion with warning [21]; AN/I discussion [22]; Block notice [23] (14 mins after block) | 2 mins | 00:38, 7 March 2009 Ddstretch unblocked (Blocking admin is involved (he/she interacted with Malleus and Malleus was brusque with him/her), the length was excessive, and no block notice was posted) | 3 days | 10 min | |
| 00:46, 7 March 2009 | Coren (talk · contribs) (Reinstating prior block) | 2 dy 23 hr 18 min | 2 dy 23 hr 18 min | |||||
| 18:23, 10 June 2009 | Gwen Gale (talk · contribs) | Context [24] Blocked for [25] | 1 hr 40ish min | 19:22, 10 June 2009 Gwen Gale unblocked (consensus seems to be that many admins are indeed sycophants) | 1 week | 59 min | ||
| 01:14, 5 November 2009 | Georgewilliamherbert (talk · contribs) | Context [26] Blocked for [27] | User:Who then was a gentleman? warned later [28] after being blocked for taunting MF's block | ANI review [29] | 24 hours | 24 hr | ||
| 08:20, 11 December 2009 | Georgewilliamherbert (talk · contribs) | context [30] incl. edit-warring on MF talk page [31] [32] [33] | User:Andrea105 blocked for 5 sec | 5 hr | 10 seconds | 10 sec | ||
| 17:21, 7 February 2010 | David Fuchs (talk · contribs) | [37] | Roux blocked | 10 min | 1 hour | 1 hr | ||
| 03:20, 7 March 2010 | TenOfAllTrades (talk · contribs) | Context [38] Blocked for [39] | 4 min | 03:32, 7 March 2010 Moni3 unblocked (ineffective block) [ANI thread on unblock [40]) | 24 hours | 12 min | ||
| 01:49, 11 July 2010 | Rodhullandemu (talk · contribs) | Context [41]
Discussion with warning [42] |
Rodhullandemu blocked AN thread; block reduced | 02:00, 11 July 2010 Moni3 unblocked (Oh, for Pete's sake! ) | 31 hours | 11 min | ||
| 01:27, 15 October 2010 | Georgewilliamherbert (talk · contribs) | Talk page [43] led to ANI thread [44] | 15 min | 01:42, 15 October 2010 Ucucha unblocked (borderline personal attack if any; block is not going to solve anything) [45] | 12 hours | 15 min | ||
| 16:49, 15 October 2010 | SarekOfVulcan (talk · contribs) | [46] | none | none | 2 min | 18:40, 15 October 2010 SarekOfVulcan unblocked (not in the mood) | 12 hours | 1 hr 51 min |
| 13:16, 3 February 2011 | Geni (talk · contribs) | First names or last names for underaged then married Edwardian women; for this per rationale | nil, comments blanked at time of block | nil | 9h 50m | discussion 13:50, 3 February 2011 Nikkimaria unblocked (per discussion at ANI and elsewhere, block was excessive) Relevant links: ANI, User_talk:Geni/archive_7 (sections 151-156), User_talk:Malleus_Fatuorum/Archives/2011/February#Blocked | 24 hours | 34 min |
| 02:58, 26 October 2011 | Kaldari (talk · contribs) | Grammar disagreement[47] and subsequent edit war over personal attacks[48][49] | Attempts to remove personal attack[50][51], AN/I thread | Tbhotch warned for calling Malleus "narrow-minded"[52] | 0 mins (discussion was ongoing) | 03:45, 26 October 2011 Mkativerata unblocked (ANI is clear. I made the call not to block. An editor does not get blocked because one out 2,000 administrators happens upon ANI and decides to. First come, first served.) | 24 hours | 47 min |
| 22:34, 21 December 2011 | Thumperward (talk · contribs) | 23:47, 21 December 2011 John unblocked (Per consensus at AN/I; disproportionate block contravenes policy) | indefinite | 1 hr 13 min | ||||
| 07:17, 22 December 2011 | Hawkeye7 (talk · contribs) | 15:51, 22 December 2011 Salvio giuliano unblocked (unblocking for the limited purpose of responding to an Arbcom request) | 1 week | 8 hr 34 min | ||||
| 23:08, 22 December 2011 | 28bytes (talk · contribs) (Reinstating prior block) | Reinstated block at Malleus request | 6 dy 3 hr 19 min (user request) | 6 dy 3 hr 19 min |