Legality of Cannabis by U.S. Jurisdiction

Content deleted Content added
Declining submission: v - Submission is improperly sourced (AFCH)
Commenting on submission (AFCH)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{AFC submission|d|v|u=Karkafs Desiderium|ns=118|decliner=Johannes Maximilian|declinets=20240127140537|ts=20240121161543}} <!-- Do not remove this line! -->
{{AFC submission|d|v|u=Karkafs Desiderium|ns=118|decliner=Johannes Maximilian|declinets=20240127140537|ts=20240121161543}} <!-- Do not remove this line! -->

{{AFC comment|1=Regarding [[Special:Diff/1199715324]]:

• The majority of the cited sources don't seem to discuss this draft's topic (Kurds in Caucasia)
• Multiple cited sources are not very useful (e.g., the sources referred to in footnotes 1 and 12)
• There is a significant logical break: The draft discusses "Kurds in Caucasia", but then describes Kurds in Kazakhstan ''without'' citing a single source that discusses why this connection ought to be made, i.e., I suspect [[WP:SYNTH]];
• No source seems to discuss the number that expresses the entirety of Kurds in the Caucasus, i.e., [[WP:SYNTH]] or [[WP:OR]] was used to obtain that figure;
• Some parts of the text directly address the reader.

One could argue that the cited sources do not indicate notability, but I doubt that peoples or ethnicities cannot be deemed notable, and thus I'd argue that the cited sources are insufficient, hence the verifiability decline. Note that topics related to Kurdish Nationalism might be considered controversial, so a very good sourcing is required, and I'd be more strict in this case. But another AfC reviewer might see it differently. Best regards, --[[User:Johannes Maximilian|Johannes]] ([[User_Talk:Johannes Maximilian|Talk]]) <small>([[Special:Contribs/Johannes Maximilian|Contribs]]) ([[User:Johannes Maximilian/Articles2|Articles]])</small> 22:10, 27 January 2024 (UTC)}}

----


{{Short description|History of Kurds from Caucasia/the Caucasus}}
{{Short description|History of Kurds from Caucasia/the Caucasus}}

Revision as of 22:10, 27 January 2024

  • Comment: Regarding Special:Diff/1199715324:
    • The majority of the cited sources don't seem to discuss this draft's topic (Kurds in Caucasia)
    • Multiple cited sources are not very useful (e.g., the sources referred to in footnotes 1 and 12)
    • There is a significant logical break: The draft discusses "Kurds in Caucasia", but then describes Kurds in Kazakhstan without citing a single source that discusses why this connection ought to be made, i.e., I suspect WP:SYNTH;
    • No source seems to discuss the number that expresses the entirety of Kurds in the Caucasus, i.e., WP:SYNTH or WP:OR was used to obtain that figure;
    • Some parts of the text directly address the reader.
    One could argue that the cited sources do not indicate notability, but I doubt that peoples or ethnicities cannot be deemed notable, and thus I'd argue that the cited sources are insufficient, hence the verifiability decline. Note that topics related to Kurdish Nationalism might be considered controversial, so a very good sourcing is required, and I'd be more strict in this case. But another AfC reviewer might see it differently. Best regards, --Johannes (Talk) (Contribs) (Articles) 22:10, 27 January 2024 (UTC)


Kurds in Caucasia
Kurdên li Kafkasyayê
Total population
208-218 Thousand or 258-268 Thousand (Including Kazakh Kurds)
Regions with significant populations
Caucasus: Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia and Russia. (And Kazakhstan)
Languages
Kurdish (Kurmanji), Azeri, Armenian, Georgian, Russian. (And Kazakh)
Religion
Sunni Islam, Shia Islam, Yazidism
Related ethnic groups
Iranian Peoples

Kurds in Caucasia are ethnic Kurds wich live in the region of the Caucasus, this includes countries like Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia and Russia. Across all of Caucasia there are around 208-218k ethnic Kurds. The first Kurds in the Caucasus region can be traced back to the mid 10th Century.[1] A lot of Kurds from the Caucasus have been deported to Central Asia in the 1930s and 1940s.[2][3]If you include Kurds from Kazakhstan, the number of Kurds from the Caucasus is between 258-268k.

Population

Population of Kurds in Caucasia
Country/Region Population Year Source
Armenia 37,470 2011 [4]
Azerbaijan 70,000 2011 [5]
Georgia 50-60,000 2014 [6]
Russia 50,701 2021 [7]
Caucasia (Total) 208-218k all of the above [7][4][5][6]

Religion

Armenia

In Armenia the majority of Kurds are Yazidis, the latest armenian census from 2011[4] recorded 35,308 Yazidis and 2,162 Kurds (meaning muslim Kurds), since in Armenia Yazidis and Kurds are seen as two different Ethnic groups.

Georgia

Group of kurdish Soldiers in 1877

In Georgia Yazidis are seen as ethnic Kurds by the georgian Goverment, the number of Yazidis in Georgia has steadily declined since 1989.

Number of Yazidis in Georgia
Year Population Source
1989 30,000 [8]
2002 18,000 [8]
2015 6,000 [8]
Kurd from Russia (taken between 1845 and 1916)

Russia

The russian census from 2021 counts Yazidis and Kurds (muslims) as two different groups, the majority of Kurds in Russia are Yazidi.

Number of Yazidis & Kurds in Russia
Group Population Year Source
Yazidis 26,163 2021 [7]
Kurds (Muslims) 24,538 2021 [7]

Caucasia

Across all of Caucasia, the precise number of Muslim Kurds and Yazidi Kurds is unknown. In Armenia and Russia Yazidi Kurds are the majority though.[4][7]

History of Kurdish States in Caucasia

Shaddadid Dynasties 951-1199

Map showing the Territory of the Shaddadids in the 12th Century

The History of Kurds in Caucasia goes back to the 10th Century, in 951 the Shaddadid Dynasty was established at Dvin by Muhammad ibn Shaddad (Arabic: محمد بن شداد; Kurdish: محمد بن شەداد), the Shaddadid Dynasty reached its greatest extend in 1030, during wich it included territories from modern-day Armenia and Azerbaijan. In 1067 the Shaddadids became a Vassal state of the Seljuk Empire after the death of Abu'l-Aswar. The Shaddadid State (of Dvin & Ganja) was fully annexed in 1075 by the Seljuk Sultan Alp Arslan, the Dynasty survived in Ani through Manuchihr ibn Shavur. The Shaddadid Dynasty of Ani was independent for another almost 100 years, until the Georgian King George III of Georgia annexed all of Ani for Georgia in 1161. The Shaddadids would rule over Ani again after a coalition of Muslim states defeated Georgia in 1163, though they were a Vassal of Azerbaijan. In 1174 Ani would again be occupied by Georgia, after switching sides between Georgia and the Shaddadids for another 4 times the Shaddadid family lost all power over Ani in 1199.[9][1][10]

Kurdistan Uezd 1923-1929

Kurdistan Uezd (also known as "Red Kurdistan") was a Soviet administrative unit wich existed as an Autonomous region inside the Azerbaijan SSR for 6 years. Its Capital was Lachin, overall the region was majority Kurdish. In 1929 the Azerbaijani Congress of Soviets dissolved the Autonomous Region.[11][2]

Territory of Kurdistan Uezd, Kurdistan Okrug and the Kurdish Republic of Lachin

Kurdistan Okrug 1930

The administrative unit of Kurdistan Okrug only existed for around 2 months after being dissolved because it strained relations between the Soviet Union and Iran and Turkey.[2]

Kurdish Lachin 1992

Kurdish Lachin (Officially: English: The Kurdish Republic of Lachin; Kurdish (Kurmanji): Komara kurdî ya Laçînê)) was a unofficial Republic wich existed for one year during the First Nagorno-Karabakh War, its Territory was the same as that of Kurdistan Uezd and later Kurdistan Okrug. It was backed by Armenia, and when their support stopped in late 1992 the state was dissolved.[12][13]

History of persecution of Kurds from Caucasia

Deportation of 1937

The First Deportation of Kurds from Caucasia to Central Asia occurred in 1937, Joseph Stalin did not trust the Kurdish population and ordered their forced Deportation to Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan. This group of Kurds from the first Deportation by Stalin came from Nakhchivan (Part of Azerbaijan SSR). Most of them died during the deportation.[14]

Deportation of 1944

The second Deportation occurred in 1944, this time the Kurds who were deported came from Georgia SSR. Again on the order of Joseph Stalin.[14]

Kurds from Caucasia in Kazakhstan

History

The Kurdish Population in Kazakhstan is descendent from Kurds from Caucasia (mostly Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia SSR), who have been deported to Central Asia in 1937 and 1944. Some Kurds from the Caucasus who were Deported to Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan later migrated north to Kazakhstan in 1990 because of the Osh Riots.[14]

Population

The Population of Kurds in Kazakhstan has steadily increased since 1970.

Population of Kurds in Kazakhstan
Year Population Source
1970 12,313 [15]
1979 17,692 [15]
1989 25,371 [15]
1999 32,764 [15]
2009 38,325 [15]
2019 46,348 [15]
2023 49,355 [15]

Religion

Most Kurds in Kazakhstan are Muslim, 98.3% of Kurds are Muslim and 0.52% are Christian.[16]

Language

88.7% of Kurds in Kazakhstan speak Kurdish (Kurmanji) as their mother tounge.[16]

Kurdish in Schools & Newspapers

Places in Kazakhstan in wich Kurds are a substantial part of the population often teach Kurdish literature and the Kurdish Language in primary and secondary school. Since 1990 there is a Kurdish newspaper in Kazakhstan named "Kurdistan".[3]

See also

References & Sources

  1. ^ a b Foundation, Encyclopaedia Iranica. "Welcome to Encyclopaedia Iranica". iranicaonline.org. Retrieved 2024-01-21.
  2. ^ a b c "ПАРТИЗАНЫ НА ПОВОДКЕ". www.hist.ru. Retrieved 2024-01-21.
  3. ^ a b "KurdishMedia.com: News about Kurds and Kurdistan". web.archive.org. 2012-03-25. Retrieved 2024-01-21.
  4. ^ a b c d https://armstat.am/file/doc/99478353.pdf Retrieved Jan/20th/2024 via Statistical Committee of Armenia
  5. ^ a b "Azerbaijan's Kurds Fear Loss Of National Identity". Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty. 2011-07-01. Retrieved 2024-01-20.
  6. ^ a b "Refworld| Georgia:Treatment of the Kurds, in particular of Yezidi Kurds".
  7. ^ a b c d e "Ethnic composition of Russia 2021". pop-stat.mashke.org. Retrieved 2024-01-20.
  8. ^ a b c staff, DFWatch. "Yazidi temple, third in the world, opened in Tbilisi". Democracy & Freedom Watch. Retrieved 2024-01-20.
  9. ^ Studies in Caucasian History. New York: Taylor’s Foreign Press. 1953. ISBN 0-521-05735-3.
  10. ^ "Meyyāfāriḳīn Tarihi'nde Kafkasya". Marmara Türkiyat Araştırmaları Dergisi (in Turkish). 9 (2): 538–549. 2022-12-19. doi:10.16985/mtad.1161329. ISSN 2148-6743.
  11. ^ The Kurds: a contemporary overview. Routledge-SOAS politics and culture in the Middle East series. London: Routledge. 1992. ISBN 978-0-415-07265-6.
  12. ^ "The Kurdish Republic of Lachin being declared in 1992".
  13. ^ "THE KURDS REMAIN CAUGHT IN THE "TRANSCAUCASIAN TRIANGLE"". Jamestown. Retrieved 2024-01-21.
  14. ^ a b c Kassymova, Didar; Kundakbayeva, Zhanat; Markus, Ustina (2012-05-18). Historical Dictionary of Kazakhstan. Scarecrow Press. ISBN 978-0-8108-7983-6.
  15. ^ a b c d e f g "Population statistics of Eastern Europe & former USSR". pop-stat.mashke.org. Retrieved 2024-01-21.
  16. ^ a b "Wayback Machine" (PDF). web.archive.org. Retrieved 2024-01-21.