Cameron11598 (talk | contribs) →Winhunter: Case is closed |
CU/OS activity motion |
||
| Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
{{Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Motions/Header}} |
{{Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Motions/Header}} |
||
{{Clear}} |
{{Clear}} |
||
== Motion: CU/OS activity standards == |
|||
:From [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee/Procedures#CheckUser/Oversight permissions and inactivity]] |
|||
{{ivmbox||bg=#E6B0AA|1='''Original:''' |
|||
''Accordingly, the minimum activity level for each tool (based on the preceding three months' activity) shall be five logged actions, including at least one community-requested logged action. Examples of community-requested actions include suppression requests via the oversight-en-wp [[Wikipedia:Volunteer Response Team|OTRS queue]]; CheckUser requests through [[Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations]], those stemming from [[Wikipedia:Request an account|account creation requests]], those made in response to threads at an administrative noticeboard, or posted on a CheckUser's personal user talk page. These activity requirements do not apply to: sitting members of the [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee|Arbitration Committee]]; or holders who have temporarily relinquished access, including CheckUsers or Oversighters who accept appointment to the [[m:Ombudsman Commission|Ombudsman Commission]].'' |
|||
'''and:''' |
|||
''Holders of the permissions are also expected to:'' |
|||
*''Remain active on the English Wikipedia unless they have previously notified the Arbitration Committee of a significant expected absence and its likely duration.'' |
|||
*''Consider temporarily relinquishing their permission(s) for planned prolonged periods of inactivity.'' |
|||
*''Reply within seven days to email communications from either the Audit Subcommittee or the Arbitration Committee about their use of the permissions.''}} |
|||
{{ivmbox||bg=#7DCEA0|1='''Replaced with:''' |
|||
''Accordingly, the minimum activity level for each tool (based on the preceding three months' activity) shall be five logged actions. Consideration will be given for activity and actions not publicly logged, such as responding to requests on the Checkuser or Oversight [[Wikipedia:Volunteer Response Team|OTRS queues]]; participation on list discussions; activity at [[Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations]]; responding to [[Wikipedia:Request an account|account creation requests]]; and responding to Checkuser or Oversight requests on administrative noticeboards, [[WP:UTRS|UTRS queue]], and user talk pages. These activity requirements do not apply to: (a) sitting members of the [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee|Arbitration Committee]]; (b) holders using the permissions for audit purposes; or (c) holders who have temporarily relinquished access, including CheckUsers or Oversighters who accept appointment to the [[m:Ombudsman Commission|Ombudsman Commission]].'' |
|||
'''and:''' |
|||
''Holders of the permissions are also expected to:'' |
|||
*''Remain active on the English Wikipedia unless they have previously notified the Arbitration Committee of a significant expected absence and its likely duration.'' |
|||
*''Consider temporarily relinquishing their permission(s) for planned prolonged periods of inactivity.'' |
|||
*''Reply within seven days to email communications from the Arbitration Committee about their use of the permissions.''}} |
|||
:''{{ACMajority|active = 12 |inactive = 2 |recused = 0 |motion = yes}}''<!--DeltaQuad, Ks0stm inactive--> |
|||
;Support |
|||
# The proposal is to update the language and examples in the existing outdated policy to better reflect functionary areas of activity and current practices. '''[[User:Mkdw|<span style="color:black;text-shadow: 4px 4px 15px white, -4px -4px 15px white">Mkdw</span>]]''' [[User talk:Mkdw|<sup>''<span style="color: #0B0080;text-shadow: 4px 4px 15px white, -4px -4px 15px white">talk</span>''</sup>]] 20:29, 25 September 2018 (UTC) |
|||
;Oppose |
|||
# |
|||
;Abstain |
|||
# |
|||
;Comments by arbitrators |
|||
===Community comments=== |
|||
Revision as of 20:29, 25 September 2018
Motions
Motion: CU/OS activity standards
Original: Accordingly, the minimum activity level for each tool (based on the preceding three months' activity) shall be five logged actions, including at least one community-requested logged action. Examples of community-requested actions include suppression requests via the oversight-en-wp OTRS queue; CheckUser requests through Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations, those stemming from account creation requests, those made in response to threads at an administrative noticeboard, or posted on a CheckUser's personal user talk page. These activity requirements do not apply to: sitting members of the Arbitration Committee; or holders who have temporarily relinquished access, including CheckUsers or Oversighters who accept appointment to the Ombudsman Commission.
and:
Holders of the permissions are also expected to:
- Remain active on the English Wikipedia unless they have previously notified the Arbitration Committee of a significant expected absence and its likely duration.
- Consider temporarily relinquishing their permission(s) for planned prolonged periods of inactivity.
- Reply within seven days to email communications from either the Audit Subcommittee or the Arbitration Committee about their use of the permissions.
Replaced with:
Accordingly, the minimum activity level for each tool (based on the preceding three months' activity) shall be five logged actions. Consideration will be given for activity and actions not publicly logged, such as responding to requests on the Checkuser or Oversight OTRS queues; participation on list discussions; activity at Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations; responding to account creation requests; and responding to Checkuser or Oversight requests on administrative noticeboards, UTRS queue, and user talk pages. These activity requirements do not apply to: (a) sitting members of the Arbitration Committee; (b) holders using the permissions for audit purposes; or (c) holders who have temporarily relinquished access, including CheckUsers or Oversighters who accept appointment to the Ombudsman Commission.
and:
Holders of the permissions are also expected to:
- Remain active on the English Wikipedia unless they have previously notified the Arbitration Committee of a significant expected absence and its likely duration.
- Consider temporarily relinquishing their permission(s) for planned prolonged periods of inactivity.
- Reply within seven days to email communications from the Arbitration Committee about their use of the permissions.
- For this motion there are 12 active arbitrators. With 0 arbitrators abstaining, 7 support or oppose votes are a majority.
- Support
- The proposal is to update the language and examples in the existing outdated policy to better reflect functionary areas of activity and current practices. Mkdw talk 20:29, 25 September 2018 (UTC)
- Oppose
- Abstain
- Comments by arbitrators